4 ms·

People ARE buying federal bonds at that rate, right? You can find a figure for the sales, look at the yield curve, and quantify exactly how many people are act

by jbooth 11y ago

People ARE buying federal bonds at that rate, right? You can find a figure for the sales, look at the yield curve, and quantify exactly how many people are acting that way with their own money (or how much money, at least). Looking at http://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/data-chart-center/interest-rates/Pages/TextView.aspx?data=yield http://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/data-chart-center/in..., the yield for 10 years is actually more like 2%. Less than a year is very close to 0, so there are apparently a ton of people out there who will lend you money for 1 year at 0.33% interest.

lmm 11y ago
There are a ton of people out there who will lend the fed money at that rate. But the fed is in a rather special position.
- msandford 11y ago
  They're not loaning it to the Fed, they're borrowing it from the Fed and loaning it to the Treasury. By doing it this way everyone gets to pretend that the Fed isn't the entity buying government debt, and so it's not "monetizing the debt" and therefore -- somehow miraculously -- it isn't outright theft. Ultimately though it's not as though banks are making the decision to loan to the Treasury at very low rates all by themselves. It was coordinated how the money flows would happen and it would do two things: allow the banks to repair their balance sheets through "free money" loans and also help the government out of a bind where there was nobody to buy their debt that they desperately needed in order to fund expansions of social services during the downturn. Personally I think that it's pretty immoral to steal from savers to bail out borrowers, but that's because I'm a saver who's been locked out of the housing market by not having gotten in prior to prices going 2x, 3x, 5x or whatever. Ultimately I think the whole thing is going to end very badly, but of course I have no idea how long it'll take. It might take another 2-3 years, it might take another 20-30. No way to know how long the speculative mania will last.

by jbooth 11y ago

lmm 11y ago

There are a ton of people out there who will lend the fed money at that rate. But the fed is in a rather special position.

msandford 11y ago
They're not loaning it to the Fed, they're borrowing it from the Fed and loaning it to the Treasury. By doing it this way everyone gets to pretend that the Fed isn't the entity buying government debt, and so it's not "monetizing the debt" and therefore -- somehow miraculously -- it isn't outright theft. Ultimately though it's not as though banks are making the decision to loan to the Treasury at very low rates all by themselves. It was coordinated how the money flows would happen and it would do two things: allow the banks to repair their balance sheets through "free money" loans and also help the government out of a bind where there was nobody to buy their debt that they desperately needed in order to fund expansions of social services during the downturn. Personally I think that it's pretty immoral to steal from savers to bail out borrowers, but that's because I'm a saver who's been locked out of the housing market by not having gotten in prior to prices going 2x, 3x, 5x or whatever. Ultimately I think the whole thing is going to end very badly, but of course I have no idea how long it'll take. It might take another 2-3 years, it might take another 20-30. No way to know how long the speculative mania will last.