5 ms·
> Life is impermanent, so should buildings. That seems to be some very silly reasoning. Should we build our roads and bridges to be impermanent, because life i
by oh_sigh 11y ago
> Life is impermanent, so should buildings.
That seems to be some very silly reasoning. Should we build our roads and bridges to be impermanent, because life is? I'm not arguing with your first sentence, about it not being surprising that unmaintained structures tend to deteriorate.
- groutexpectatio 11y agoInfrastructure is not permanent. 'We' don't build roads and bridges to last, governments might run a cost-benefit analysis or a net present value and build a project out to where it makes sense given time money and interest. Bridges need repair, asphalt cracks and wears, re-bar rusts and compromises concrete from the inside, infrastructure depreciates. The ancient world, some of those things, are built to last--- because they're made from solid stone and such.
- stcredzero 11y agoThat seems to be some very silly reasoning. It's not so silly when your culture is situated right on the Pacific "Ring of Fire" as is the case for Japan. In times past, you wanted to make your houses light, so that if there is an earthquake, less stuff falls on you and your family. Imagine what it would be like if the entire culture was constantly metaphorically whispering to you from the moment of your birth about the temporary nature of life? Sorry, but while you can tell yourself you're doing it, you can't actually do it -- your imagination isn't that good! (Otherwise, there would be far fewer systemic social problems.) In Japan, there is no distinction between high and low art. (This is absolutely related to the rest of this comment!)
- oh_sigh 11y ago> Imagine what it would be like if the entire culture was constantly metaphorically whispering to you from the moment of your birth about the temporary nature of life? Are you implying that people think the world ends when they die? If I'm going to do useful work, why not do useful work that will help out people even after I'm dead? Right now I'm living in a building that was built in the 1880s. I'm happy that they built it to last.
- stcredzero 11y agoAre you implying that people think the world ends when they die? Non-sequitur!
- oh_sigh 11y agoThen what were you trying to say? How or why have the Japanese built temples, shrines, and castles that that have lasted thousands of years if they are constantly told how transient life is?
- stcredzero 11y agoThere's different messages for the common folk and the ruling elites.
- oh_sigh 11y agoIt sounds like you're just making up facts to fit your theory.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mc32 11y agoI say that because society changes and as I changes our needs change. We used to need gigantic factory mills, now we don't. We used to want intertwined road networks, now we're rethinking that. We may want to build subway lines where we didn't imagine we'd need them,at the same time we want to shutter stations we no longer need. She we start out from living with parents or guardians a studio suffices, then onto bigger dwellings, then we retrench as we become older. Ps. Not to mention natural disasters and climate change, either modern or historic ala Maya or Saharan changes, for example. So, yes, design with impermanence in mind.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoNot so sure. Like hosting an AWS cloud, you want some more-or-less permanent hosts and some as-needed instances. Housing can certainly benefit from some well-built century houses that get moved in and out of as generations age. And during a rapid expansion etc, then some temporary.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]