2 ms·
I think it's also important to understand that before the Communists took power, China had spent more than a century being trampled by various foreign powers, s
by mikeash 11y ago
I think it's also important to understand that before the Communists took power, China had spent more than a century being trampled by various foreign powers, starting with the British and expanding from there, and finally ending with the Japanese rampaging through the country in the lead-up to WWII.
Under the Communists, China put a stop to all of this and became a major power again. There are certainly problems in China, but the average person is way better off today than before the Communists took over, and not just because of economic growth.
Now, one can argue that the Communists weren't necessary to make this happen, or that they even impeded progress. (Fighting a civil war and the Japanese at the same time certainly wasn't very helpful.) But the fact remains that they were the ones in charge while this change took place, and they get a lot of credit for that.
- brc 11y ago"Great Leap Forward"? Improvements only came when they abandoned communism, and came up with a fig leaf of 'mao was 80% correct' It is hard to rewrite history with a different set of rules, but I think it's fair to say that given the experience of Hong Kong, China would have been better off without 30-40 years of communist rule.
- monort 11y agoNot only Hong Kong, Taiwan and Singapore too. It's an experiment with control groups.
- brc 11y agoYes in my haste I forgot that Taiwan is the perfect A/B test control group, because of the postwar history. It had a lot of the same issues to overcome. I am biased towards Hong Kong having visited and loved the place, so it's always the first one I think of.
- mikeash 11y agoWell yes, I covered that in my last paragraph. It may well be fair to say that. But it doesn't change the fact that the Chinese Communist Party presided over a period which took China from the world's punching bag to a strong, independent power. Maybe they made it happen, maybe it happened despite them, maybe it's a mix, but they get a lot of credit from the population for being the ones in control while it happened.