8 ms·
First thought: seems like Mechanical Turk is popular in India.
by olalonde 17y ago
First thought: seems like Mechanical Turk is popular in India.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- myoung8 17y agoThere also appear to be MTurk "shops"--some of the people are clearly sitting at the same computer (some even used the exact same sign...)
- delano 17y agoYeah I noticed that too. There's also some location inconsistencies! http://www.thestever.net/viewer.php?num=33 http://www.thestever.net/viewer.php?num=33 http://www.thestever.net/viewer.php?num=34 http://www.thestever.net/viewer.php?num=34 http://www.thestever.net/viewer.php?num=35 http://www.thestever.net/viewer.php?num=35
- aonic 17y agoHere as well, look at the closet on the right and the pictures on the wall. http://www.thestever.net/viewer.php?num=10 http://www.thestever.net/viewer.php?num=10 http://www.thestever.net/viewer.php?num=14 http://www.thestever.net/viewer.php?num=14 http://www.thestever.net/viewer.php?num=45 http://www.thestever.net/viewer.php?num=45 http://www.thestever.net/viewer.php?num=42 http://www.thestever.net/viewer.php?num=42 http://www.thestever.net/viewer.php?num=41 http://www.thestever.net/viewer.php?num=41 http://www.thestever.net/viewer.php?num=32 http://www.thestever.net/viewer.php?num=32 http://www.thestever.net/viewer.php?num=31 http://www.thestever.net/viewer.php?num=31 http://www.thestever.net/viewer.php?num=30 http://www.thestever.net/viewer.php?num=30 http://www.thestever.net/viewer.php?num=29 http://www.thestever.net/viewer.php?num=29
- eli 17y agoThat doesn't indicate a formal "shop" to me. If you're getting $1 for each picture of a person holding a sign you submit, you might as well have everyone else in the room take a turn.
- khandelwal 17y agoThat makes sense. $1 is 40 Indian Rupees, and $50 (the prize money) is 2339 Indian Rupees at current rates. Neither amount is an insignificant amount of money in India.
- nishantmodak 17y agoIf $1 = Rs. 40 Then $50 = Rs. 2000 Yes. Neither amount is insignificant. But I still wonder, why only India? People from Pakistan, China and even Sri Lanka , Singapore are in +/- 3 hrs. timezones. The timing of the post would be crucial to understand this.
- robotrout 17y agoIndians speak English.
- nearestneighbor 17y agoFewer than 10% (almost all of which speak it as a second language)
- nishantmodak 17y agoSo do people from Singapore, Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh, Hong Kong, Thailand, Malaysia, Iran.
- agravier 17y agoFYI, $1 is insignificant in Singapore. Average household monthly income probably around 4000 USD (personal estimate, I live there, didn't look for official data)
- paraschopra 17y agoWhat irks me that as an Indian I can't create a job on MTurk! I would love to try MTurk but it is only open for US citizens..
- jacquesm 17y agoIt shouldn't just irk you as an Indian, it irks me as a dutch person as well. If a service finds people from a certain country good enough to be 'minions' how come it finds them not good enough to be 'bosses' ? This is actually a really nice opportunity to give amazon a run for their money and to set up a competing service that operates world-wide on both the give and the take side.
- paulsilver 17y agoThere are employment laws in the UK which mean a Mechanical Turk-like system wouldn't be able to have jobs listed for such low amounts - I think it comes under the minimum wage laws. Because of this and similar laws in other countries, Amazon have kept job-posting MT accounts limited to the USA at the moment, which doesn't have the restriction. I don't know enough about Dutch or Indian law to know whether a similar system could be set up within them, but there are problems with rolling something like this out globally.
- jacquesm 17y agoMinimum wage laws only apply to a situation where there is an employer-employee relationship between the two parties, this is much more like a free-lance situation.