2 ms·
How on earth was communism an example of "open"?
by idlewords 17y ago
How on earth was communism an example of "open"?
- anigbrowl 17y agoWell, superficially it sounds like pure economic democracy - anyone who has a good idea that would benefit people proposes it, and resources are allocated to them by consensus. That's the seductive part, but it takes no account of the variations in intelligence, foresight and altruism, which is why it only works in Star Trek. I don't think communism is evil so much as fundamentally naive, its proponents assume the mass of people think alike and that selfishness is a learned behavior imposed from above by wicked capitalists. It lasted as long as it did in the USSR because both military and scientific folk are into the idea of setting aside individual gain for a greater purpose, such as patriotism or the advancement of knowledge. Communism is bad if you look at it from the perspective of a democracy with a functioning market. Then again, that perspective is a luxury if you have the misfortune to be stuck in a feudal society - most places where it took root were extremely dysfunctional monarchies prior to turning communist. Aristcracies aren't what we'd call ideal societies either; even here in the west, the replacement of aristocracy by parliamentary government was viewed by traditionalists as a form of godless mob rule. And it's not that long ago that people were complaining that GPL represented a kind of license tyranny which would undermine proprietary innovation.
- idlewords 17y agoI don't think your answer makes much sense. Historically, communism had to do with allocation of resources by the state rather than a market, in the service of certain ideological beliefs. 'Openness' was not one of them.