4 ms·
I think you're missing the point, the article is pretty much a direct response to: http://googleblog.blogspot.com/2009/12/meaning-of-open.html http://googleblo
by mattmanser 17y ago
I think you're missing the point, the article is pretty much a direct response to:
http://googleblog.blogspot.com/2009/12/meaning-of-open.html http://googleblog.blogspot.com/2009/12/meaning-of-open.html
(submitted here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1008908 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1008908)
In it a Google open source zealot rants wildly about openess being ultimate, apart from search algorithms which should be closed. It also fails to mention all the times open has failed (communism being one of the more spectacular failures of open).
A cynic might surmise what they actually mean is content should be open so they can profit from their closed search algorithm.
- jedc 17y agoIt was written by Jonathan Rosenberg, who's a Senior Vice President for Product Management, and on the top management committee at Google. That doesn't quite meet my personal description of an "open source zealot", though he's clearly quite passionate about it.
- RyanMcGreal 17y ago> communism being one of the more spectacular failures of open Wait, what? Communism is a spectacular failure of centralized planning over the entire economy. It has nothing to do with open or closed in principle, and in every implementation it has been aggressively closed in terms of information flows and decision making.
- jacquesm 17y ago> Communism is a spectacular failure of centralized planning over the entire economy. Wow, and here I was thinking it was a form of government. Communism in principle has absolutely nothing to do with the flow of information and/or decision making, and its implementations have only very little to do with its basic ideas. A true communistic government has never even been tried, we've only seen a 'new boss same as the old boss' approach to communism with one batch of fat cats replacing another.
- mbreese 17y agoI believe that Communism is largely an economic system with politics being aside effect of the economic model. For example, the opposite of Communism isn't democracy, it's capitalism. And actually, in the purest sense, Communism is completely about decision making. According to that bastion of scholarly thought Wikipedia: "Pure communism" in the Marxian sense refers to a classless, stateless and oppression-free society where decisions on what to produce and what policies to pursue are made democratically, allowing every member of society to participate in the decision-making process in both the political and economic spheres of life. But that's one of those theory and practice things... great in theory, horrible in practice.
- RyanMcGreal 17y ago>Wow, and here I was thinking it was a form of government. Like most ideologies, the term "communism" is gooshy enough to mean whatever you want it to mean - but at heart, communism is concerned with the matter of who owns and controls the means of production. It's a form of government insofar as the decision on who gets to control the means of production is ultimately a political decision. Communists believe the people should own and control the means of production - but every real-world implementation has used government as a proxy for people. I suppose it's possible to run a communist society via direct democracy on a very small, local scale; but good luck trying to scale that up to the national or even regional level. At some level you need to adopt some kind of more or less representative government. In the case of communism, the track record is definitely skewed toward the "less" end of the representation spectrum. In other words, your claim: >A true communistic government has never even been tried... is a straightforward No True Scotsman fallacy. It's no different from "real" conservatives distancing themselves from the Bush administration because the implementation of their political system ended up violating most of its ostensible core values. If you can't implement an ideology without discarding the very principles that define the ideology, it's a broken ideology.
- Semiapies 17y ago"It's no different from "real" conservatives distancing themselves from the Bush administration because the implementation of their political system ended up violating most of its ostensible core values." To define American-style conservative and liberal philosophy as what the Republican and Democratic parties and their politicians do is ridiculously simplistic. The parties are just coalitions of interests and voter demographics, not philosophies - you might as well talk about what direction a plate of spaghetti points at. And as for conservatives' "political system" - whose? Do you mean evangelicals and other theocrats, PNAC neocons, populist teabaggers, or Lew Rockwell/Ron Paul fans? We're not talking remotely the degree of unity imposed by the Politburo and Comintern upon the global communist movement when it comes to either US party. In a bipolar system, both parties must be big tents or be crushed by the bigger tent. Elected officials are not (and Bush was not) advancing a single "conservative" or "liberal" ideology; they're trying to please various power blocs who agree or disagree with them on different issues. Bush's failures highlight the failure of particular policies and ideas, but they don't say much about the ideas of self-described "real conservatives" who thought Bush was a ridiculously free-spending, anti-federal, protectionist, power-consolidating, Big Government guy long before Iraq. (No more than Obama's decisions indict the ideas of supporters who disagree with him on those decisions, certainly.)
- idlewords 17y agoHow on earth was communism an example of "open"?
- anigbrowl 17y agoWell, superficially it sounds like pure economic democracy - anyone who has a good idea that would benefit people proposes it, and resources are allocated to them by consensus. That's the seductive part, but it takes no account of the variations in intelligence, foresight and altruism, which is why it only works in Star Trek. I don't think communism is evil so much as fundamentally naive, its proponents assume the mass of people think alike and that selfishness is a learned behavior imposed from above by wicked capitalists. It lasted as long as it did in the USSR because both military and scientific folk are into the idea of setting aside individual gain for a greater purpose, such as patriotism or the advancement of knowledge. Communism is bad if you look at it from the perspective of a democracy with a functioning market. Then again, that perspective is a luxury if you have the misfortune to be stuck in a feudal society - most places where it took root were extremely dysfunctional monarchies prior to turning communist. Aristcracies aren't what we'd call ideal societies either; even here in the west, the replacement of aristocracy by parliamentary government was viewed by traditionalists as a form of godless mob rule. And it's not that long ago that people were complaining that GPL represented a kind of license tyranny which would undermine proprietary innovation.
- idlewords 17y agoI don't think your answer makes much sense. Historically, communism had to do with allocation of resources by the state rather than a market, in the service of certain ideological beliefs. 'Openness' was not one of them.
- showerst 17y agoThanks for the link, that helps put the post into a bit more context. That said, I think the author's point is still wrong. As a community, we have to understand that these open systems are an enabler of progress, some of which will undoubtedly be proprietary. Part of openness is understanding that you're not locking people into using this stuff, and they're not locked in to how they use it. I don't see it as hypocritical that a business can talk about being open and how critical it is to give back, while still keeping trade secrets to pay the bills. I recently saw the CEO of the Economist group speak about journalism, and one thing he said (paraphrasing) was that the best defense of journalistic impartiality in the modern age is to turn a healthy (and diversified) profit. The subtext was that you can then risk offending any given party by doing good reporting without the appearance of favoritism, and without having a corporate (or nonprofit) master to please. In the same sense I think that the best defense of free software is to allow companies to use it on their own terms, and give back when they can/will. The most useful open source projects are used (and likely abused) ad-nauseum, and trying to limit any company, even one that preaches hypocritically about open source is a recipe for them to tell the community to shove it and go hand money to <insert big vendor here>. While it's fairly easy to preach the open-source gospel to fellow programmers and nerds that appreciate the value of this stuff, it's business people and non-tech-literates that oftentimes allow the checks to be signed, and the open source community needs to look to them like a group of enablers, not inflexible idealogues.