3 ms·
> If Google has to delist an article about a private citizen's minor indiscretions, I disagree, but it's small potatoes. There's a reason the "slippery slope"
by smt88 11y ago
> If Google has to delist an article about a private citizen's minor indiscretions, I disagree, but it's small potatoes.
There's a reason the "slippery slope" is such a popular phrase in legal discussions. What exactly is "minor"? Who is a "private citizen"? Where do you draw those lines? Everything is a spectrum.
In order to arbitrate in situations where there are shades of gray, we need judges. But laws such as this are impossible to bring before a judge due to their quantity, and there isn't necessarily a single party "damaged" by the takedowns, which makes it even less plausible. There is a public interest in having this information, and it's hard to get individuals in a free society to spend a lot of time and money fighting for public interest.
If you're against this law in some cases, you have to be against it in all cases.
- hyperpape 11y ago> If you're against this law in some cases, you have to be against it in all cases. I don't know what this is supposed to mean. Of course, if I am against a law, I think it should not exist. And that covers all cases. But equally obviously, I can say that there are cases where applying the law has better or worse consequences.
- smt88 11y ago> I have to admit there are cases that I find innocuous when considered by themselves I was referring to that statement. It's never "innocuous" because there's no universal, objective guideline for what is innocuous and what isn't. Something that seems innocuous to you as a spectator may not be for people involved.
- hyperpape 11y ago"It's never harmful because there's no universal, objective guideline for what is harmful and what isn't".