3 ms·
The intent is not to make it impossible to find out about things, but to make it sufficiently more effort to find out about things that the harm to the individu
by vidarh 11y ago
The intent is not to make it impossible to find out about things, but to make it sufficiently more effort to find out about things that the harm to the individuals in question is sufficiently reduced.
It is very explicitly a tradeoff where everyone involved understands that the information won't go away, and where the courts have very explicitly said they will not consider trying to make the information go away as that would fly in the face of freedom of speech.
The ease of access to information has a very substantial bearing on how much having the information out there affects peoples lives.
- Kalium 11y agoThe intent is to deny many someones access to public information for the convenience of one someone. This is censorship by degrees. You'll have to pardon me. I'll be over here, in the corner, throwing up.
- kodablah 11y agoPersonally, I find this a dangerous way of thinking. A real "right to be forgotten" law would affect content providers/publishers. Instead this is more "right to de-index". Ease of access is very subjective and the arbiters appear to be the ones holding the gun shooting said messengers. Despite my other concerns with the legislation, the primary reason it works today is because of centralization. The same people fighting for internet privacy and against government censorship will end up making laws like this unenforceable in the future. I wonder what lengths the EU will then go to when the indexing of lawful content is not centralized.
- kuschku 11y agoWell, imagine I get suspected of a crime, turns out I actually wasn’t responsible. Obviously, you can’t remove the newspaper article, even if it is heavily editorialized. But removing the connection between my name and that article would be possible. If someone searches for the specific article, they’ll find it. If they search for my name, they won’t. A reasonable compromise (all data is still there and readable, but my name isn’t connected with it anymore).
- bdhe 11y ago> Obviously, you can’t remove the newspaper article, even if it is heavily editorialized. Wouldn't it be easier to have a law requiring that if the newspaper article is online, then they MUST have some sort of Editor's Note or retraction in bold before the actual article.
- kuschku 11y agoWe do, but (a) international media does not have to adhere to that law (for example, a newspaper in Switzerland could still contain such an article), and (b) tabloids like BILD ignore that regulation anyway and even end up showing themselves as the only newspaper that fights against the evil censorship.
- Maken 11y agoNone of those points support censoring media that do follow the European regulations. The current "Right to be forgotten" is just an ambiguous law's backdoor that lets you hide information without having to pass through the courts.