3 ms·
I don't see what the disagreement is. Somebody (e.g. Billybob) does something stupid that winds up on the local news sites. 6yr later the court case is long s
by dsfyu404ed 11y ago
I don't see what the disagreement is.
Somebody (e.g. Billybob) does something stupid that winds up on the local news sites. 6yr later the court case is long since closed and he wants it behind him because it was a just a drunken mistake. EU says he has a right to be forgotten which he exercises. Google deference the news articles from Billybob's name. Billybob Google's himself and finds a blog about Google referencing search results that mentions him by name and the nature of the result. Since it mentions him by name it's a primary result (you Goggle Billybob and it comes up) and Google should have to remove it per the law.
Obviously this sort of law creates an incentive for background check services to just crawl every news site imaginable which could create a whole set of different problems but that's beyond this scope...
I think it'll just take time for society to understand that people do stupid shit and ignore it as long as it's irrelevant to the context and "forgetting" events is just a stopgap. Eventually people will realize that racists, political extremists and people with non-violent felonies can still function normally from 9 to 5 and this will be a non issue.
This problem has a lot in common on the technical side with dragnet surveillance and law enforcement. Google needs to determine what is and isn't relevant when returning results for somebody. Some misdemeanor in highschool is of dubious relevance 10yr after the fact and if the person apparently has a lot of results that paint a picture of them having a successful career and generally having moved on. Google could put that on the 3rd or 4th page, after all the "people named $name in $state" public records databases, where it's practically forgotten. Meanwhile the NSA (or whoever) needs to figure out how to filter out and avoid flagging for followup that sound like flags but are actually sarcastic, based on inside jokes, or obvious false positives when considered in context (to avoid wasting their time,wasting our money and violating people's privacy).
- spinlock 11y ago> Obviously this sort of law creates an incentive for background check services Bingo
- x0x0 11y agoYet you'll note that things like credit services are, at least in the united states because that's what I'm familiar with, regulated. You have to be able to see the information and there is a process to contest inaccurate information, with government penalties if the companies don't comply. And there is enforced forgetfulness: negative credit information is removed from your report generally after 7 years. I rather doubt google wants to be so regulated; like many internet companies, they want to have their cake and eat it too.
- notahacker 11y agoStill sounds like a boon to the people most likely to send out these requests to me. Scenario 1. HR scans resume, types name into Google, finds Github profile and a couple of headlines in local newspaper about arrest, discards CV Scenario 2. HR scans resume, types name into Google, finds Github profile and forwards to dev team. Interview arranged as goes well and offer is made pending background check. Company pays $30 to agency who confirms grades and work history and additionally reveals that you were arrested but not charged for a misdemeanour when you were a teenager In the second case, there's a pretty good chance the candidate will actually get the job.
- thrownaway2424 11y agoNot being a full-time European I find this example fishy. In the USA arrest records of minors are sealed, even in case of trial and conviction. Nobody in the USA is publishing news articles about misdemeanor or even felony arrests of teenagers, unless the crime is very notorious. Is that not the case in Europe?
- FilterSweep 11y agoThis is a great comment, and it actually highlights some additional problems with it all. Let's say your name was "Mike Smith." Pretty common name, right? Even if HR took your Hiring Scenario 1, it will be most likely it will take until the offer-pending-official-background-check is made. Why? Because "Mike Smith" brings up hundreds and thousands of results even with a geolocated search. Living in a city of several million is a boon to reformed misdemeanor teen Mike Smith. That's not even considering the legitimate criminal Mike Smith's that need to be ignored for our innocent Mike Smith's sake. Now, if your name was "Quincy Brouwer" (Dutch Surname), its easier for this arrest to pop up. The reality of the situation, at least from what I've seen, is that there is a hybrid of Scenarios 1 & 2 that actually go on. they will do some rudimental Googling on your name, but it won't be until the offer is about to be made that they'll do the formal, paid, background check and look into your credit history and other things. Unfortunately on the other side of the coin, for developers in particular, many will go through several rounds of sometimes grueling technical interviews only to find out a silly mistake they made as a youth disbars them from the job.
- FilterSweep 11y ago> I think it'll just take time for society to realize that people do stupid shit and ignore it as long as it's irrelevant to the context and "forgetting" events is just a stopgap This is a great point and it ties into a relatively new change in the cultural landscape from "no news is good news" to "_any_ news is bad news." Search Engines are often the culprit, as well. Not a fully accurate example, but it describes the situation - Suppose CS student BillyBob got drunk out with his freshmen friends at a bar night, and he really needs to pee. he climbed the fence into a construction area and was soon arrested for trespassing along with charges for being drunk in public / whatever else is related to the charge. To his dismay, he ends up on several public news site, despite the judge writing off the offense and letting him go free. He finished his CS degree with honors. These news sites do not really care that his charge was far more innocent than, a guy who assisted in something far more malicious, say, the Watergate scandal, and yet his chances of finding future employment are reduced drastically as he easily appears in search results. IMO, the new normal works like a boolean, either flagged or not flagged. This is irrespective of his efficacy as a developer, and the fact that he learned from a college mistake. :ED: Didn't see you updated your post to include a similar situation. In sum, I think the Right to be Forgotten was a good idea, but it was not implemented correctly.
- x0x0 11y agoThe same way that software, the nsa, and ubiquitous cameras with facial recognition changed surveillance, google changed knowledge discovery. The laws that were appropriate when surveilling a person meant dedicating a set of human beings to following someone, thus naturally limiting the scale, fall apart when it can all be done electronically at vastly higher scale for very little marginal cost. Similarly, the laws that worked when information was naturally forgotten because we had limited ability to index and discover it, ie you could always do deep background checks on someone, but it was very labor intensive and thus pricey, need rewriting now you can get the equivalent of an fbi background surveillance check by typing a name for tiny effort and cost. Hence jerks like Eric Schmidt suggest people should change their name if they want not to have youthful hijinks follow them around, yet is happy to use his billions and lawyers to keep his mistresses' stories off the internet.
- dynomight 11y agoWell put. The title of the original article is unnecessarily confusing and probably purposely made so for ironic effect.