3 ms·
My wife went to a Shang-Gri-La school until high school. No really, it sounds like a fantasy to me still. She decided on her curriculum from 1st grade onward an
by Balgair 11y ago
My wife went to a Shang-Gri-La school until high school. No really, it sounds like a fantasy to me still. She decided on her curriculum from 1st grade onward and she decided on her tests. Yes, heavy guidance from teachers and parents here, but she did push back and insist on certain areas like dance and swimming. The ethos of the school was self improvement. She gave herself grades. Yes really. Here's the site: https://sites.google.com/a/bvsd.org/horizonsk8/ https://sites.google.com/a/bvsd.org/horizonsk8/
Granted this is Boulder CO, and it was 2 decades ago. As far as she has told me, it was public at that time too. Yes, that was/is a public school, money comes from the state and parents. https://sites.google.com/a/bvsd.org/horizonsk8/supporting-horizons https://sites.google.com/a/bvsd.org/horizonsk8/supporting-ho...
Looking at the outcomes of the students and her friends, they tend to be either PhDs or in an art collective. They all are very high preforming and great people (I did in fact marry her, so I am biased). As far as she has told me, the economic backgrounds of the kids were independent too. Our maid-of-honor and her best friend through this school came from a household tornado'd by drugs. The maid-of-honor's mother can barely hold a sentence together from all the opiate damage.
I say this because when you say "...and you can't educate high performing kids in public school." you are without any doubt completely and totally wrong.
Any school can be a great place for any child. I understand that state laws are very different here, but that is not an excuse in a democracy. Especially when you are talking about education of your children. The entire point of society, of having governments, of the whole damn species is children. Education, dollar for dollar, is by far the most important thing you can spend money on as a society or democracy. So not fighting for great public schools like the one my wife went to is just ... sad.
I'm telling you, collectives of homeschools may seem like a great idea at the time. But then you get schools like the ones in upstate NY (http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/534/a-not-so-simple-majority http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/534/a...) and other crazys hell bent on religious based discrimination. Great public schools are worth fighting for, they are worth battling entrenched unions and politicians for, they are worth sending your kids to.
I know, because my wife went to one and I didn't (http://www.drphil.com/slideshows/slideshow/2415/ http://www.drphil.com/slideshows/slideshow/2415/ http://www.calstate.edu/pa/clips2004/july/2july/ca.shtml http://www.calstate.edu/pa/clips2004/july/2july/ca.shtml). And, you know what, she's gonna be a public school teacher too.
- clavalle 11y ago>I say this because when you say "...and you can't educate high performing kids in public school." you are without any doubt completely and totally wrong. You're going to find exceptions if you take any statement as an absolute. >Any school can be a great place for any child. Could be. But the are not presently. > Education, dollar for dollar, is by far the most important thing you can spend money on as a society or democracy. I 100% agree. >So not fighting for great public schools like the one my wife went to is just ... sad. I think we should, we need to be fighting for those kinds of schools. I simply can't afford wait around for that shift to yield results. And, yes, there are some pretty wacky collectives and homeschoolers. You'd be surprised how hard it is to find course material without some sort of weird agenda baked in. But it is just wrong to paint all of them with that brush. >Great public schools are worth fighting for, Yep. >they are worth battling entrenched unions and politicians for, Agreed. > they are worth sending your kids to. Nope. That's where you lose me. What good is it for me to throw my kids into a cesspool? Will that get it cleaned up any faster? No, sorry, I'm not going to turn my kids into martyrs for what little political leverage having them in a regular public school might give me. Like you said, education is the most important thing. We are starting to see some change in public schools. I don't think it is an accident that we are seeing that change now that they have real competition. What you are asking for is a return to a broken status quo in trade for a vague hope that they get their shit together after decades of decline. We can simultaneously fight for better public schools and educate our high performers to the best of their ability.
- Balgair 11y agoI think you are wrong still, but good lord am i glad to have an honest discussion about it. I see you points and agree with a lot of them, but I think that for most folk, the only way to get them to fight for the schools is to have their kids in them, to have skin in the game. Still, thanks.