3 ms·
Evidence obtained illegally is only inadmissible if the illegal act was committed by a government agent. Evidence obtained through the illegal act of a private
by skissane 11y ago
Evidence obtained illegally is only inadmissible if the illegal act was committed by a government agent. Evidence obtained through the illegal act of a private party is perfectly admissible. See Burdeau v. McDowell: https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/256/465/case.html https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/256/465/case.htm...
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoThere's a great business model: a private company that hacks for the prosecutor in deserving cases. Probably make some good money, and do a public good!
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoSO, its only ok if its done for free? Or out of juvenile glee at hurting powerful people?
- skissane 11y agoIn a scenario in which a private actor, of its own volition and for its own reasons, decides to conduct a search, and then chooses to reveal the results of the search to the government, it is clear from Burdeau v. McDowell that evidence should not be excluded. But if a company's primary business was performing warantless searches for the government, paid for by the government and at its direction, I think it is very likely a court would find that private actor to be a government agent, and thus evidence collected should be excluded. If an arrangement exists for the primary purpose of evading the Fourth Amendment, many judges would disapprove of that and try to shut it down. But to my limited knowledge, this scenario has never been presented to a court.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoSoooo, the funding has to come from somewhere else, I get it. How about a sort of kickstarter for hacking deserving people/organizations? Just brainstorming here.