2 ms·
There are four dimensions there: happening/not, natural/anthropogenic, beneficial/harmful, and the relative economic impact of intentional terraforming efforts.
by logfromblammo 11y ago
There are four dimensions there: happening/not, natural/anthropogenic, beneficial/harmful, and the relative economic impact of intentional terraforming efforts.
Of those four, only the last two are worth debating, and they're really almost the same thing. Everyone who screams about those first two dimensions are probably profiting more by perpetuating a meaningless conversation than by solving an identifiable problem.
Sounds like a lot of political issues, actually. Some people can make a curiously prosperous living just out of getting other people to shout at each other.
- mikeash 11y agoThey all tie together, though. Yes, ultimately you just want to know what will happen if things go on as they are, and how that will change if we change our activity. But the first two strongly feed into the last two. If climate change is not anthropogenic, then cutting emissions will not provide any benefit, while potentially causing economic harm. If climate change isn't happening at all then there is no need to do anything, and the entire framework for predicting the outcomes of changes to human activities is completely busted.