4 ms·
So apple can now count money they pay to work on their compiler as a tax deduction?
by aidenn0 11y ago
So apple can now count money they pay to work on their compiler as a tax deduction?
- saosebastiao 11y agoIt always was a tax deduction for Apple. This makes it a tax deduction for companies that aren't contributing paid labor.
- DannyBee 11y agoIt's not apple or apple's compiler, just because Apple happens to use it in presentations and press :)
- teamhappy 11y agoWikipedia lists Apple as Clang's primary developer and Chris Lattner, the primary developer behind LLVM, is employed by Apple. I agree with you though, it's not Apple's compiler. // My bad; Wiki calls Lattner the "primary author," not "primary developer."
- bla2 11y agoLLVM has hundreds of developers these days. Chris wrote a ton of the initial code, but he's no longer the "primary developer". The project's big enough now to no longer have a primary developer.
- belorn 11y agoWhere ever I check, Chris is listed as lead/director for the llvm project. Isn't this exactly like the position Linus has for the Linux project?
- glhaynes 11y agoI think there's a big difference between "lead/director" and "primary". I wouldn't ever call Linus the primary developer of Linux (well, at least not after the early '90s) but "lead" sounds much closer to right.
- DannyBee 11y agoI don't think he really considers himself either at this point, to be honest. He's just a member of the board of the foundation.
- chrislattner 11y agoCorrect. If anything, I'm a founder. LLVM and Clang are much much larger than my own contributions, and I haven't been particularly active lately. That said, I have contributed a lot of code. In LLVM for example, about 20% of the total commits to the project are mine: https://www.openhub.net/p/llvm/contributors?query=&sort=commits https://www.openhub.net/p/llvm/contributors?query=&sort=comm... Luckily, the other 80% are ripping out my terrible code and replacing it :-)
- Sanddancer 11y agoAs can Google, Intel, the mesa project, and a lot of other donors and contributors. As much as certain people would like for you to believe otherwise, llvm is far, far bigger than any one company.
- DannyBee 11y agoWhat he said. LLVM these days is huge.
- Someone 11y agoIt hasn't been an all Apple show for quite a while. If you look at the past meetings on http://llvm.org http://llvm.org, the first few mostly had speakers from Apple and academia, but for instance http://llvm.org/devmtg/2010-11/ http://llvm.org/devmtg/2010-11/ (November 2011) already has speakers from Google, AMD, ARM, Sony Pictures and Ericsson Research.
- 15155 11y agoThat was always a tax deduction - it's business labor. They can now deduct additional (donated) funds paid directly to LLVM. As would every other company who wants to see LLVM flourish.
- dankohn1 11y agoCompanies don't take tax deductions the same way as individuals. For individuals, charitable donations are made with pre-tax money. So if you pay taxes at a 33% rate and give $100 to the EFF, it's $67 of your regular post-tax income you're contributing, and $33 of what would otherwise be tax revenue. For companies, essentially all expenses are deductible, and they pay corporate tax on what is left over. Corporate taxes are on profits, which are revenues minus expenses. So, there is no advantage to Apple or any other company in providing funding to a 501(c)(3) vs. a 501(c)(6) trade group or a consulting firm. And, I doubt that LLVM will be raising that much deductible money from individuals. But, there is also a branding and marketing aspect to tax status, separate from the actual financial implications.