3 ms·
This is one of those situations where it would be great to have slides detailing points of the video. His are just drawings of some people's names and time poin
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
This is one of those situations where it would be great to have slides detailing points of the video. His are just drawings of some people's names and time points. I love the retro, sketch-style art but it doesn't tell me a thing. Several minutes in of rambling and I still don't know what it's about. Click the little X...
So, out of thousands of vids on the net on OSS or programming... each 20+ min long... why watch this unless I'm already a fan of the authors work? Not even critiquing the presentation as much as saying: give us a matching article or slides that lets us determine if we really want to watch the video. If it strikes a chord, people watch the presentation. Otherwise, most will just skip it and miss out on any gems it might have had. And that's a rational decision given the flood of info on the web.
This applies to a ton of videos rather than just @fat's. Anyone having to do a lot of research or want to get most out of their time relies on summaries. People not doing them are reducing impact of their own work.
- AndyKelley 11y agoI completely agree. I came to the comment section in attempt to get such an overview to determine whether the video was worth watching.
- ZenoArrow 11y agoScroll through until you see a slide about cute puppy syndrome (I think that was what it was called). You'll miss the buildup and the fun presentation of open source history but that's the key part of the talk. To spoil it slightly, it's about the lifecycle of open source projects.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoDidn't see this one when I posted my other two comments. So, that's three comments that do a bit of what author didn't. Merging them together mentally gives me an idea of what to expect. Even an abstract saying about the same as you did would've been nice.
- daveidol 11y agoI enjoyed it. The entire talk isn't about the history of open source - he eventually gets into issues about maintaining open source in modern day on GitHub.
- nickpsecurity 11y ago1 of 2 comments that help solve the problem AndyKelley and I have with it. Appreciate it. :)
- r3bl 11y agoI remember I watched this quite a while ago and it was a pleasant experience. If I remember correctly, the video was very funny. I'm re-watching it right now.
- vacri 11y agoIt's a talk at a conference; it's not designed to be a web video talk. In context, those slides are fine - it's a lightweight entertainment talk about FLOSS history and opinion.
- nickpsecurity 11y ago2 of 2 comments that help solve the problem AndyKelley and I have with it. Appreciate it. :)