4 ms·
On a tangent but, we have self-driving cars, perhaps we should have lawyer robots as well soon ;-) Maybe point Watson to all the case history and see what he c
by rdtsc 11y ago
On a tangent but, we have self-driving cars, perhaps we should have lawyer robots as well soon ;-)
Maybe point Watson to all the case history and see what he can do.
It is funny how we read the article yesterday about the "New Aristocrat" class. Maybe automation will replace the Aristocrat class at some point for a change...
- ghaff 11y agoNot lawyer-Watson, but there are already an increasing number of automated systems in use for discovery, case law search, etc. This is one of the reasons that there is a glut of lawyers. There's less need for a lot of the highly-paid but entry-level grunt work that newly-minted law school grad associates did historically.
- rayiner 11y agoI don't know if I really believe that. Predictive coding has a high set up cost (training the algorithm), which makes it uneconomical unless you've got a really big document review. But those big document reviews are often in big lawsuits where the parties aren't as budget conscious. Outsourcing to human contract lawyers is almost always more cost-effective. I think legal technology,[1] explains very little of the glut of lawyers. Mostly because it's really not very useful so it doesn't get used that widely. The real answer is that the job situation for lawyers isn't much different than nearly any other white collar profession. The amount of legal work per unit GDP is pretty steady, GDP isn't growing rapidly, and schools graduate way more students than the industry can absorb. [1] Obviously lawyers use the same technology that has helped everywhere else. PDF instead of paper copies, email, outsourced IT, etc.
- ghaff 11y agoI'm by no means an expert on the field but I have at least read credible cases for technology being part of the reason, e.g. http://www.nytimes.com/2011/03/05/science/05legal.html http://www.nytimes.com/2011/03/05/science/05legal.html That said, I'm also imagine part of it is just the same technology that is helping everyone else, albeit in a particularly paper-intensive field that requires enormous amounts of searching and checking.
- hirsin 11y agoIt's often simpler than that. You have a corpus of knowledge that you need to dig through. Cases are interconnected by footnotes (i.e. case X referenced precedent set in case Y [and succeeded]). The relative strength of referencing a case is predicted by the number of references made to it [successfully]. The biggest use of highly-paid, entry-level law grads was to run from case book to case book, chasing down all those footnotes and getting photocopies of them. Digitizing them (i.e. OCR, make them searchable) and turning footnotes into hyperlinks basically negates the entire point of those entry-level grads. So, no use of predictive algorithms or fancy ML - just PageRank applied to a set of case books.
- rayiner 11y agoThe downturn in the demand for "highly-paid entry level grads" is quite recent, and driven mostly by the general economic downturn in the U.S. Slower growth = fewer transactions that need to get papered and fewer busted deals that turn into litigation. Meanwhile, West/Lexis went electronic in the 1970's, and electronic research has been standard at business law firms probably for the last 20-30 years. In any case, the process of legal research was probably faster than you think pre-computers, because cases were all indexed by West/Lexis on the basis of their content. So even back in the days of book research, the primary use of young associates was, as it is today, discovery, not research. And it's funny you mention PageRank. Google Scholar has gotten better for legal research, but it's still vastly inferior to old-school search queries in WestLaw. PageRank is pretty much useless for legal research. The strength of referencing a case has nothing to do with how often it's cited, but the similarity in the factual/legal scenario in that case compared to your own.[1] A case nobody cites that addresses the specific wrinkle of the law your situation falls into is infinitely more authoritative than one that's highly cited for some generic principle of law. [1] PageRank is pretty good at finding seminal/controversial cases in an area of law, but that's rarely useful. You already know what those are, because you paid at least a modicum of attention in law school and/or you started your research by reading a chapter in the relevant treatise, which lays those cases out for you.
- hirsin 11y agoYou got me - I only play a lawyer on TV. Thanks for the perspective, is West/Lexis still hiring people to read over content and rank/organize it?
- Apocryphon 11y agoWhat should we call the outgrowth of "sharing economy+" apps that aren't about volunteers doing menial tasks, but professionals? Because at least one app that turns legal aid into a blackbox service exists, in S.F. at least: http://www.fixed.com http://www.fixed.com There's several for medical services, as well. http://www.wsj.com/articles/startups-vie-to-build-an-uber-for-health-care-1439265847 http://www.wsj.com/articles/startups-vie-to-build-an-uber-fo...
- monochromatic 11y agoProfessions that require human judgments will be the last to fall to the machines. We won't have automated lawyers until we have strong AI.
- TheCapn 11y agoYep. The law isn't necessarily "logical" as one judge can interpret situations or deem "justice" differently from the next.
- ghaff 11y agoFurthermore, as someone I know is fond of saying, the law doesn't compile cleanly. If you think you've uncovered a loophole that lets you murder someone in a tiny slice in Idaho (http://loststates.blogspot.com/2011/08/loophole-landwhere-crimes-cant-be.html http://loststates.blogspot.com/2011/08/loophole-landwhere-cr...) and no one can do a darned thing about it... well, no, you almost certainly won't just waltz away untouched while the legal system shrugs.
- rdtsc 11y agoAt some point factory work on the assembly line required human judgement too. Now they have robots that sort, assemble & select widgets. 100 years ago telling someone that factory jobs will go away would have been met with disbelief just like telling someone that lawyers will go away is today perhaps.
- clavalle 11y agoProfessions that require creativity of a type that relates deeply with human experience will the the last to fall.
- terminado 11y agoSounds like a great recipe for an arms race, nuanced communication break-down, and total dissolution of civil values amongst peers, dehumanizing everyone to each other more than ever before, as we refuse to even face each other even when litigating to resolve a conflict.
- IndianAstronaut 11y agoOr the possibility of a switch from an adversarial to a truth finding judicial system.