8 ms·
Has anyone else noticed that the conservative rhetoric has quietly switched from "global warming doesn't exist so we don't have to do anything" to "global warmi
by jedberg 11y ago
Has anyone else noticed that the conservative rhetoric has quietly switched from "global warming doesn't exist so we don't have to do anything" to "global warming isn't caused by people so there is nothing we can do"?
- savanaly 11y agoYes, other people have noticed that.
- zajd 11y agoI think you'll find (and the comments on this story illustrate the point quite succinctly) that there are still many idiots who are willing to tow the "human driven climate change is a made up thing" Sad but true
- braythwayt 11y agoI think “toes the line” is an expression literally meaning, “To advance to the start of a race.” From there, we get the idea of participating in something, and from there we get conforming to rules or standards. As in, “Raganwald has a potty mouth in person, but he toes the line and respects HN’s guidelines for civil discussion."
- dhimes 11y agoI understand that the term is nautical: http://www.seatalk.info/cgi-bin/nautical-marine-sailing-dictionary/db.cgi?db=db&uid=default&FirstLetter=t&sb=Term&view_records=View+Records&nh=4 http://www.seatalk.info/cgi-bin/nautical-marine-sailing-dict...
- braythwayt 11y agoThere seems to be some uncertainty about its origins, with some saying sports, many cite “toeing the plank,” and a few other explanations: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toe_the_line https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toe_the_line
- davidw 11y agoI'd be curious to understand why some people seem to be offended by the idea that people cause global warming. I flag all these articles though, because they always end up about politics, given that scientists are mostly in consensus, and very few people here are climate scientists.
- caseysoftware 11y agoWell, if you accept that humans are a major cause of global warming, the equation becomes pretty simple: Limit human behavior or limit the number of humans. Both have scary ramifications.
- yongjik 11y agoHumans were a major cause of acid rain and the ozone hole. We more or less solved these problems, by "limiting human behavior", and most people didn't even notice. I don't see why people should be so scared by more solar (or even nuclear) plants.
- sanderjd 11y agoEven if you don't accept that humans are a major cause of climate change, but you do accept that it is happening, will have disastrous consequences for human survival, and can be mitigated through human action, the equation becomes simple. The "can be mitigated through human action" seems to get tied up in, "humans are a major cause", but they aren't actually the same thing. Instead of the backwards-looking "you did this" slap on the wrist, we should be selling the aspirational "you can help solve this" call to action.
- m_fayer 11y agoThe idea that limiting human behavior is a scary concept makes no sense to me. We limit human behavior all the time because resources are finite and because the immediate interests of the individual may be detrimental to wider society. It's called rule of law.
- lotharbot 11y ago
- cryoshon 11y agoYou'll also find many conservatives who will allege that the NOAA has been manipulating their data and "changing the numbers" to make the case for a warming planet. Nevermind that any European or Chinese or Russian climatology group would deliver the exact same data...
- sanderjd 11y agoI've always found it incredibly frustrating that both sides focus so much on "is it caused by people". It makes things personal, it sounds to many people like an accusation – "you're ruining the world just by living your life" – which (understandably!) makes people defensive, and it's completely beside the point. There are only two relevant questions: 1. Is it happening? and 2. What can we do right now to fix it? The answer to (1) seems to be "yes", but while I do hear lots of discussion about different answers to (2), I hear even more about all this stuff that's happened in the past and can't be changed. Don't get me wrong, it is definitely important for scientists to understand how our behavior impacts the climate, in order to make intelligent proposals about how to fix things, but it's purely a distraction in the policy discussion. Even if we determine that humans have had nothing to do with the looming crisis, we still need to figure out how to fix it, if we want to survive. If lived in an era with an impending but completely naturally occurring ice age, we (or, at least, many of us) would still be trying to figure out how to stop it, or survive it.
- logfromblammo 11y agoThe question I would like answered is "What is the optimal mean surface temperature of the Earth?" It's hard for me to get all worked up over climate change when no one can tell me whether the observations indicate a trend towards or away from an overall improvement. It's easy to show that things are changing. It's slightly more difficult to show that such changes are resulting from human activity. But no one seems to know whether things are accidentally getting better or accidentally getting worse. How would anyone know what to "fix" if they can't even identify what is broken? It's like everyone is engaged in an archery contest, and the location of the bulls-eye is revealed only after everyone shoots. You can't correct your aim if you don't know what you're shooting at.
- asgard1024 11y ago> The question I would like answered is "What is the optimal mean surface temperature of the Earth?" I think I can answer that: the way it always was. Adaptation is always a cost, regardless of the direction. Not only human cost, but also cost for the ecosystems. If the change is fast enough it may cause migrations or extinctions.
- downandout 11y agoBy "conservative rhetoric" I assume you mean the only scientifically provable stance that there is on the issue.
- edgyswingset 11y agoIt's widely accepted in the scientific that specific occurrences such as the ozone hole above Antarctica are created as a result of human activity in the past 50 years.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- downandout 11y agoPlease state your politically-neutral, credible, scientific source for this comment.
- edgyswingset 11y agoPlease state yours!
- talmand 11y agoMy usual perusal through political talk hasn't shown that. I still see several references claiming that global warming isn't real. There still seems to be quite a few variations of talking points on both sides of the equation.
- jellicle 11y agoAnd don't forget "global warming is inevitable now, so there's nothing we can do". In my experience a good Fox News segment can use all three of these, at the same time, and switch back and forth among them, with no cognitive dissonance apparent. I don't think any of them are really being phased out, it's just that if any particular one is defeated in conversation, the arguer switches to one of the other arguments. EDIT: Indeed, there are several HN comments in this thread to that effect.
- mikeash 11y agoIt has been that way for a very long time now. The right-wing angle on the debate has always included: - It's not happening. - It's happening but it's natural. - It's happening and might be man-made, but it's beneficial. - It's happening and might be man-made, and it's harmful, but it's not worth the cost to mitigate. - It's happening and might be man-made, and it's harmful, and free-market solutions will solve it. And yes, it often freely switches between them depending on the context.
- logfromblammo 11y agoThere are four dimensions there: happening/not, natural/anthropogenic, beneficial/harmful, and the relative economic impact of intentional terraforming efforts. Of those four, only the last two are worth debating, and they're really almost the same thing. Everyone who screams about those first two dimensions are probably profiting more by perpetuating a meaningless conversation than by solving an identifiable problem. Sounds like a lot of political issues, actually. Some people can make a curiously prosperous living just out of getting other people to shout at each other.
- mikeash 11y agoThey all tie together, though. Yes, ultimately you just want to know what will happen if things go on as they are, and how that will change if we change our activity. But the first two strongly feed into the last two. If climate change is not anthropogenic, then cutting emissions will not provide any benefit, while potentially causing economic harm. If climate change isn't happening at all then there is no need to do anything, and the entire framework for predicting the outcomes of changes to human activities is completely busted.
- patrickaljord 11y agoI don't think it's called global warming anymore, it's called climate change. Besides, I don't understand why it's ok for liberals to make fun of conservatives using "extreme snow" during winter as an argument against climate change but that liberals using exceptional heat during summer as an argument for climate change is ok. A few months of extra cold or heat is not enough to prove or disprove climate change. Last year we had an unusual cold summer, was that proof that climate change is not happening? We already have good scientific ways to measure climate change, let's stick to these (carbon emission etc). I think we should start focusing on real solutions. Many conservatives are right to underline that simply increasing taxes is not the solution. So what's the solution? Innovation in new source of renewable or less polluting energy technologies. Both liberals and conservatives tend to agree here but they diverge in methodology. Liberals want to heavily tax fossil and subsidize renewable energy. Problem with that is that taxing fossil make life and the economy harder in the meantime and subsidizing often goes to cronies which is bad for innovation. Conservatives prefer having better environment for businesses which will boost innovation. Maybe there's some middle ground in there.
- davidw 11y ago> conservatives using "extreme snow" during winter as an argument against climate change but that liberals using exceptional heat during summer The 'extreme snow' was limited to certain parts of the US - the west coast got very little on the whole. Whereas this high temperature data is a global average. So they're not really the same thing. > I think we should start focusing on real solutions. Sounds good to me. Taxes, it must be said, are also a way to spur innovation, because it can focus people's attention on using less of the taxed resource. Here's Greg Mankiw's take on that. He's a Republican economist. http://gregmankiw.blogspot.com/2006/10/pigou-club-manifesto.html http://gregmankiw.blogspot.com/2006/10/pigou-club-manifesto....
- Frondo 11y agoThe fossil fuel industry folks, and the politicians they fund, are the ones who politicize this issue. Please don't turn this into a "liberals said, conservatives said" thing. If there wasn't a ton of fossil fuel money on the line, there never would have been any public confusion or discussion about AGW--the science would simply have been acknowledged and we've have moved onto engineering solutions. (As for the "conservatives prefer better environment for business.." you ought to look at how well the economy has done under liberal vs conservative leaders all throughout the 20th century to gain some insight into which political leanings are better for the economy, of which business is, of course, a major part.)