7 ms·
Since 1880 Edit: I normally don't react to downvotes but this is a direct quote. Larger context: this was also the all-time highest monthly temperature in the
by ams6110 11y ago
Since 1880
Edit: I normally don't react to downvotes but this is a direct quote. Larger context: this was also the all-time highest monthly temperature in the 1880–2015 record, at 61.86°F (16.61°C), surpassing the previous record set in 1998 by 0.14°F (0.08°C)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- fluidcruft 11y agoIt's pretty easy to understand why it's being downvoted. It doesn't contribute to the conversation--it's a pedantic tangent that isn't any more interesting than noting that (1) the surface of the Earth used to be molten and (2) all matter in the known Universe was a lot hotter during the big bang. Is that relevant?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- inversionOf 11y agoThe surface of the Earth was molten some 4.5 billion years ago. The big bang was about 14 billion years ago. The start of the relative record is a mere 135 years ago. It is absurd to conflate the two, and it's a critical foundation for the statement. By simple random odds (which given that weather stations are few and far between, simple odds of micro-climates can shift temperature slightly), even with zero influence of global warming or any other effect, it's entirely possible to break records set over such a short period. I'm far too lazy to calculate random odds right now, but setting a new high at a 17 year interval doesn't seem remarkable. It is in the context of global warming, but in isolation it really doesn't mean much. This isn't an anti AGW comment, and it's unfortunate that it's impossible to even state something so fundamental without it becoming religious, but the truth is that we've been recording our planet for a very short period of time, with growing accuracy and coverage every year.
- mikeash 11y agoComments like these are not appreciated not because they're wrong, exactly, but because they're useless and irrelevant. Imaging we have a coin that I claim is biased. (Just pretend that front-page story about how it's impossible to bias a coin didn't happen.) I've flipped it dozens or hundreds of times and nearly every time it comes up heads. After I've done this for a while, I start saying, check this out, I'm pretty sure this coin is biased. I provide my data to support the claim. But it's an ongoing investigation, so I'm still flipping the coin, and it keeps coming up mostly heads. Every so often I publish a confirming tidbit, like, "I just flipped the coin 5 times and every time it came up heads. This is even more confirmation that it's biased." What you're doing is basically taking that statement and saying, that doesn't mean anything, a fair coin would produce 5 heads in a row 1 out of every 32 attempts. Then I do another experiment, flip the coin four times and each time it's heads. Your reply is that it's meaningless because a fair coin would reproduce this 1 out of every 16 attempts. Another experiment. Six heads. You say it's meaningless, because a fair coin would do this 1 out of 64 times. And we keep on going. With each announcement you point out, correctly, that this specific, individual result could pretty easily occur by random chance. And yet each of your responses is useless and misguided, because it ignores all the other results. Setting a new high is not remarkable. Doing it repeatedly starts to get more interesting. Doing it while average temperatures have been rising steadily for over a century is more compelling. Put all the data together and, while each little piece can be said to mean little because it could have happened by random chance, the sum total is highly compelling.
- inversionOf 11y agoComments like this (and predictable moderation of my comment) are what makes this whole discussion a religion. You profoundly and completely missed the entire context of my comment in your zeal to, you think, denounce anti-warming. It is tiring, pedestrian, and ignorant.
- mikeash 11y agoMaybe if you explained a little more, I could actually have a shot at understanding what you think the problem is.
- nitrogen 11y agoIf so, it's not nearly to the extent of modern temperature increases, and modern CO2 increases are certainly not part of a preindustrial trend.
- wsterling 11y agoYour comment just seems redundant. The title says "ever recorded" right in it. It does not simply say "Hottest Month Ever".
- soneca 11y agoNot redundant at all. 'Recorded' could mean since 1930 or 1600. It was a useful comment for me
- magicalist 11y agoWell "recorded" already narrows it down to the history of thermometers (largely 17th century and later), then the very first bullet point in the article mentions that the dataset is 1880–2015, which really clears that matter up, I'd say. So, "useful" in the sense of "let me summarize the article in two words so you can reach your own conclusions instead of clicking that link and reading NOAA's". Semi apologies for the snark, but yes, the first comment really was an almost informationless attempt to derail. Success!
- JustSomeNobody 11y agoThey didn't record anything before 1880? I don't think the clarification deserved down votes.
- stevewepay 11y agoHow exactly do they do a fair comparison between 1880 and today? I'm assuming the temperature readings today are very accurate, but how accurate were the measuring devices going back in history, and their standards for taking temperature? Most of the thermometers I have in my house are +- 2F, which would eliminate the differences entirely.
- cryptoz 11y agoThere are significant temperature records that go back much farther than 1880 even. Many navies and armies kept records from all over the world, so we actually have lots more data than people think. There are also bodies of science that deal with 'aftcasting', which is making a weather forecast for a date in the past. These techniques have been refined to the point where we can make 1-day aftcasts for ~1850 that are comparable to modern 2-3 day weather forecasts in terms of accuracy, even with the limited data available (things like barometric pressure readings from ships). I'm not sure about the technology used at the time, but the basic answer to your question that that they had a lot more thermometers than you expect, distributed globally too. And as we're discussing global averages, the noise about +-2F in your house isn't really the same problem. Edit: Here's a neat 100-year reanalysis paper if you're interested. Abstract link here, full pdf available on the page: http://journals.ametsoc.org/doi/abs/10.1175/BAMS-87-2-175 http://journals.ametsoc.org/doi/abs/10.1175/BAMS-87-2-175. "Feasibility of a 100-Year Reanalysis Using Only Surface Pressure Data"
- rnovak 11y agoTo be honest, and this is my opinion only, but 2-3 day forcasts, at least in my area, are horribly inaccurate. In my state, it's a common joke that being a meteorologist is the only job you can have where you can be wrong 95% of the time, and still keep your job. Seriously, our forecasts are nearly always wrong. So.....saying we can make as accurate of forecasts for 200 years ago...that's not really saying much. This is after moving to two cities in the same state, more than 100 miles apart, the forecasts still never get better.
- alelefant 11y ago
- pbreit 11y agoSo is that a long time or a little?
- shogun21 11y agoIn the lifetime of the planet Earth, this is only a little sliver we're looking at. It is important to note that we've been recording since the industrial revolution so this could be the result of human influence.
- malchow 11y ago"A little sliver" indeed! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:All_palaeotemps.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:All_palaeotemps.png