3 ms·
Well that's a nonsensical question to pose. First of all, harsh is subjective. Prosecutors don't dole out "harsh" sentences, they dole out longer or more restri
by peterwwillis 11y ago
Well that's a nonsensical question to pose. First of all, harsh is subjective. Prosecutors don't dole out "harsh" sentences, they dole out longer or more restrictive sentences. To them, the sentence is not harsh because they're keeping innocent civilians safer by keeping criminals behind bars longer, or by making it easier to send potentially harmful people back to prison. Prison is no longer seen as a way to be penitent about one's actions: prison is now seen as a way to keep the bad away from the good.
The rate of crime may have dropped, but the kind of crime did not, and prison gangs certainly haven't diminished in size or scope. People seem to forget that going to prison is a way of life to many people. Keeping those people 'off the streets' is basically the prosecutor's primary role.
- tptacek 11y agoHuh? Harsh is not only objective but trivially easy to measure. As crime rates fell, the likelihood than an arrest would convert to a felony conviction rose. That's the opposite of the causality you'd want or expect: as the community gets safer, the criminal justice system should become less intrusive, not more.
- Natsu 11y agoThere's an alternate explanation for that: that the harsher sentences made that population unable to commit further crimes by leaving them in prison. This could also be correlated with the rise in prison violence. That would tend to make sense given that prison is not a deterrent, in the sense that studies have shown doesn't seem to make people less willing to commit crimes, whereas the state of being in prison certainly does restrict their ability to do so.
- tptacek 11y agoHow does that square with the evidence that the overwhelming majority of prison inmates serve (a) short sentences (b) only 1-2 times in their life?
- Natsu 11y agoThat would seem to make sense if the three strikes laws are as significant a factor in causing the increase in felony convictions as I've been lead to believe.
- tptacek 11y agoAccording to this research, those laws are not a significant factor in the prison population. (of course, that doesn't make them a good idea!)
- dllthomas 11y agoWouldn't a less intrusive justice system only involve itself where guilt is more severe and more certain, and thus see a higher rate of felony conviction per arrest (with a much lower arrest rate)?
- tsotha 11y ago>Prosecutors don't dole out "harsh" sentences, they dole out longer or more restrictive sentences. Prosecutors "don't dole" out sentences at all. Sentencing is one of the Judge's duties. The input prosecutors have in sentencing is less direct; aside from their actual performance in the trial, they also decide which and how many charges to file for indictment.