4 ms·
A question and an observation. 1. Can anyone name a company on par with Amazon/Uber/SpaceX/Goog etc... where everyone is working 9-5? Not doubting they exist,
by AndrewKemendo 11y ago
A question and an observation.
1. Can anyone name a company on par with Amazon/Uber/SpaceX/Goog etc... where everyone is working 9-5? Not doubting they exist, it just seems like all the major high growth big vision companies have this same ethos. Maybe they are successful despite that, but that would seem anti-pattern
2. There is a subset of people who do not lose productivity after 40/50/60 hours a week (full disclosure I think I am one of these as my work weeks look closer to 80-90) and I think that is who these companies are optimizing for. Amazon doesn't care if it burns out 10 people if it can keep one that is super passionate and can work like a madman.
- georgefrick 11y agoI see lines like this sometimes, and I never speak up. So here goes. You work 16 hour days and it's just fine? You are saying that in your post. It's right there. 80-90 hours. You expect someone reading your post to believe you work 16 hour days, it's fine; you're a rock star who loses no productivity by the 79th hour on Friday evening?
- roel_v 11y agoEven if you're just 10% productive that last hour, that's still more work than someone who clocked out at 79 hours. Not saying that everybody should work 80 hours, just that this whole 'working more than 50 hours is less productive than working 40' is one of those extraordinary claims that require extraordinary evidence. Because looking at the empirical evidence, it's the companies where people work long, hard hours are the successful ones, and not just in software... Try walking into a Cravath partner meeting, or John Hopkin's neurosurgery ward, and propose people go home after 40 because it would make them 'better' - you'd get laughed out of the room, is where I'd put my money.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoThis is my point. Finance, Medicine, Legal - hell even people building pipelines or working long haul logistics etc... all have the same situations. I think there is value in companies that are 9-5, but those are not $BN high impact companies. The only major organizations with those hours are select government agencies.
- pjc50 11y agocompanies where people work long, hard hours are the successful ones Can we try a little harder than evidence-free correlation/causation here? A quick look at the world's largest companies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_companies_by_revenue https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_companies_by_r... reveals that the secret of being in the top 10 for success is to be in oil&gas, or to be Walmart. Most Walmart employees are paid by the hour and subject to varying schedules outside their control. The highest tech company is Apple at 17. Speaking of hourly pay, that is undoubtably a big reason why salaried staff are overworked: the extra hours are free to the company. It would be interesting to see how long "long hours" culture would last if every single staff hour over 40 hours a week had to be paid for. (Once we got past all the insistence that employees falsify timesheets, of course)
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoHave you ever worked an oil job? They are INSANE in terms of hours/labor. I'm from Houston and grew up in and around oil jobs. Amazon is utopia land compared with working at EXXON.
- pjc50 11y agoI have to say that, being a programmer, I have never worked an oil job. The closest I've gotten is watching the flares over Grangemouth refinery. I hear that rig jobs tend to be X weeks on/Y weeks off? Are you subject to "hours worked" safety regulations like drivers?
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoYes, line jobs and field jobs are supposed to comply with OSHA standards for working conditions and hours. However there is a lot that happens out there that isn't up to standard and as a result there are accidents that are preventable. See this humorous video for an example: https://youtu.be/p_-2Apzy5mc?t=3m23s https://youtu.be/p_-2Apzy5mc?t=3m23s I'm not even talking about field jobs though. Analysts, developers and white collar workers inside Exxon are generally expected to put in massive hours.
- georgefrick 11y agoI never said any of that. I called him out on working 80 hours; he apparently does. Good for him. That doesn't mean you should make assumptions beyond that. I'm already at 40 hours this week. So I'll hit ~60 before I go home Friday night. Second, why would I care about being laughed out of a room at those places? It's sounds like you are trying to put shame/value on not wanting to join in on the 80 hour fun. I challenge you or anyone, to actually talk about the value this provides to the employee. Go ahead and argue for 80 hours without mentioning 'successful companies'.
- joncrocks 11y agoThis is true as long as there aren't activities where you can have negative productivity. e.g. In software, in my 80th hour, I could quite easily write some code that was bad, that takes longer than an hour to work out is bad. Code that wouldn't have been written wrong if I had been thinking clearly. Hence is net negative in terms of productivity. (not saying that the point at which productivity goes negative at the 80h mark however.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoYou are assuming a 5-6 day work week. It's closer to 12-14 hours a day everyday. I am also not writing code - which I think people just assume is the case. My role as founder is super varied, so in any given day I will do a meeting or two with investors, calls with the CTO, hangout meetings, design sessions, "brainstorming" or whatever you want to call a creative process, recruiting, reading industry news, reviewing financial statements, calls with customers, customer support emails, building presentations etc... I spread this out from about 830 AM to 1 AM with most of the work from 830AM - 5PM Break for dinner and family time from 5 - 830/9 then do some of the lighter work again from 9PM - 1 AM. That works for me and my family. I have worked in much more stressful environments and can tell you for a fact that there is no dip in productivity - if anything, working less makes me antsy.
- georgefrick 11y agoSo when did you meet your wife? During a dinner break? When do you handle maintenance items? (cleaning, washing, lawn care, taxes). Should I assume this is all done by someone else? It's not realistic to bring a founder argument into the realm of a normal worker; who may or may not have a family yet, and isn't paid in the realm of affording to retain services. Maybe I'm missing something; the hours just don't add up. Do you fit all family activity into that 5:00 - 8:30 block? Son's baseball means no dinner that night? I realize I sound like a smart ass; but it's more of an accounting/detail oriented twitch. The math isn't working in my head and I'd like to understand. Edit: I do respect your work ethic, again I know I sound like a smart ass; but I'm just trying to understand. I couldn't physically work those hours and handle all of my responsibilities.
- ryandrake 11y agoYou're not being a smart ass. Either he is a robot or his numbers simply don't add up.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoMy wife does say that I'm basically a robot.
- papapra 11y agoI think the chart about perceived productivity is for you :)
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoHa, maybe but doubtful. I have been in those situations where it is very clear that productivity has dropped but people are still working and I can tell you that they make me mad. I hate wasting time, so that's really what drives my work - that my time is best used when put to something creative/productive rather than un-engaging.
- ryandrake 11y agoYour definition of success is narrow. Many companies in many industries (operating at all kinds of risk/reward levels) deliver returns that satisfy their shareholder(s). Most of them are home to traditional 9-5 jobs.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoLet's be clear here though. We aren't talking about any outcome companies. This whole thing started with the article about Amazon, which is not a company looking for an average outcome they are trying to dominate the world of marketplaces. No company that is trying to do massive huge game changing things are 9-5. That also counts for big projects (Apollo, Manhattan etc...) that have out-sized goals.
- bildung 11y ago> 1. Can anyone name a company on par with Amazon/Uber/SpaceX/Goog etc... where everyone is working 9-5? In terms of revenue? Volkswagen had a revenue of about EUR 200 billion in 2014. In Germany (where 200.000 of Volkswagens employees work), working hours are 32 hours at Volkswagen proper, and up to 40 hours at Audi, Porsche etc. And Volkswagen is a profitable company (in contrast to Uber and Amazon...).