4 ms·
I need to sit down and go through your numbers, but something does not seem right. Are you assuming everyone gets $12000 regardless of age?
by danieltillett 11y ago
I need to sit down and go through your numbers, but something does not seem right. Are you assuming everyone gets $12000 regardless of age?
- enraged_camel 11y agoIsn't it unconditional basic income, as in everyone gets the same flat amount? The moment you add conditions and variables, you basically turn it into the complex mess that's the current welfare system.
- danieltillett 11y agoIt can be unconditional and not apply to children and people collecting pensions. It would not create a huge mess by limiting it to people over 18 and under 65.
- mason240 11y agoWouldn't the simpler solution be to simply reduce the pensions by the amount of UBI? For example, a pensioner gettin $40k/year would get $25k under a $15k UBI. You would have to get them to agree to the renegotiation, so I suppose it's not a realistic solution.
- danieltillett 11y agoYes it would, although getting people to give up something is hard. Personally I would structure a UBI as a large negative income tax to try and avoid these problems.
- 3pt14159 11y agoWhy should people with pensions not get UBI? They saved their money into a pension vs into a bank account. Unless you are talking about replacing Social Security, but even there the math isn't as straightforward. As for 18 and under, I think it's a bit tough. A 6 person household with 4 kids needs much more than a 2 person household. If we don't supply UBI to the children / wards of the children then we risk needing to recreate social assistance programs. Although it does run the risk of having kids for money, which admittedly probably already happens.
- danieltillett 11y agoI was making the point that a UBI can have age exclusions and still be simple. I would be reluctant to provide a full UBI to children since they don't have the freedom to spend the money themselves.
- jholman 11y agohttp://www.census.gov/popclock/ http://www.census.gov/popclock/ 321.5 million residents gives $3.86T. Looks like each year of age under 18 makes up about 1.33% of that, for a total of 77M residents under the age of 18. Suppose you don't give a cent to anyone under 18 (which is not consistent with the UBI arguments I've seen, but whatever). 244.5M residents, times $12k, gives $2.9T. Sure, that's "residents", not "citizens". Otoh, non-resident citizens might be entitled as well. Either way, how can you argue with "over 300M times over $10k gives over 3 trillion"? Edit1: screwed up reading the graph, fixed above numbers. Edit2: oh, just saw your comment suggesting "18 to 65" Fine, integrating by eyeball the graph from my link, I see 47 years at more than 1.2% of the pop per year, gives roughly 60% of the population in your age bracket. Now it's 200M recipients, or $2.4T.
- Retric 11y agoBi has two main savings, direct welfare and indirect welfare from a flat tax rate. The vast majority of workers make over to 9,225$ per year which is taxed at 10%. If they had a 39.6% tax that's 2730.6 new taxes to offset a BI of 12000$ for a net cost of -9269.4. Next $9,226-$37,450 is at 15%, bump that to 39.6% and someone making 37,450 costs -9269.4 + 6943.104 = -2,326.30$. Now if you continue this you find a medean income gets a bigger tax break than 12,000$ per year from the graduated tax rates. Also, with BI you don't need a standard deduction... Net impact BI's are not simply whatever the BI is * the population.
- notahacker 11y ago> Now if you continue this you find a medean income gets a bigger tax break than 12,000$ per year from the graduated tax rates. You're going to struggle to sell BI on the basis that the person with a median income should make higher net tax contributions to subsidise those that won't work as well as those the present system determines "can't" work at the moment...
- rue 11y agoBasic Income does not imply a flat tax rate.
- 11y ago