> Few people can risk spending 10 years on something and have nothing to show for it. This is a common sentiment, and fortunately for scientists I don't think

> Few people can risk spending 10 years on something and have nothing to show for it. This is a common sentiment, and fortunately for scientists I don't think it's a very accurate description of the real problems we face. I really don't think that there are many good reasons to spend 10 years on one thing when there is a substantial risk of failure. Scientists spend 10 years on problems all the time! But it's either part time, or has measurable metrics for progress along the way that can be published. I mean, you try to go to the moon before Pluto, right? Science (as an institution) is really a lot more like Tetris than people think, except some of the blocks (publications) get moved or destroyed later. But if the blocks are smaller, they're much easier to fit together and build upon, and fault tolerant and so forth, so if they blow up it's less of a big deal. Smaller, more well-defined and robust studies are generally better. To change analogies to paths instead of blocks, which is a better description of the decision making a scientist goes through (rather than building the edifice of human knowledge), it's a lot more like finding your way through a new city than choosing two paths in a snowstorm that will not encounter anything for 10 years' walk. At every fork, you have to decide where to go and there will be some reason you have made that choice. After some smaller period, you can if you choose report where you've gotten and why. Other people care! They will be happy to read about it, as long as your logic is pretty good, especially if you make nice observations along the way. You can publish this, and probably no one will steal it from you. Maybe someone will... but if you do it right, do it incrementally and let people know what you're up to, you'll at least have your batshit ideas published as unreviewed abstracts and folks will know who made the first progress.