6 ms·
The University had given him a license, no?
by StavrosK 11y ago
The University had given him a license, no?
- svisser 11y agoWhich the student didn't use - he used an invalid key and obtained the software using unofficial means.
- at-fates-hands 11y agoBecause the software license was restricted to use only in the lab. The student wanted to use it while he was travelling - not an unheard of use of software, and a reasonable expectation. This was OP's point. If I'm paying for a boatload of expensive licenses, why should I be limited to how and where I use the software? Makes no sense to me.
- danielweber 11y agoCERN licensed the software exactly that way. They aren't Joe Random User. They have a purchasing department that can negotiate back with the vendor.[1] Then the student wanted to override CERN's negotiation with the vendor. [1] http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/CamelsandRubberDuckies.html http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/CamelsandRubberDuckie...
- masklinn 11y agoNot the university, CERN. As the article notes CERN's license pool is only for fixed computers (not roaming), the student wanted the software on their laptop so they went and downloaded a cracked version.
- sbuk 11y agoNo. CERN were covered by a site license. FTFA; But our student failed to download AllSIM from DFS onto his office PC, since that wasn’t where he wanted to use it. He wanted to install it on his laptop so that he could work on his simulation while travelling. However, the CERN AllSIM installation would not allow for this, as roaming usage is not covered by CERN's AllSIM licence. The student had a need and was not willing to compromise i.e. by using the Windows Terminal Service. Instead, he used Google and quickly found AllSIM for free on a dubious website. Three clicks later, he was ready to go. For convenience, the student essentially stole the license.
- gutnor 11y agoThe student didn't steal the license. He misused the license. The license for his usage existed in the pool - it is only a combination of CERN security policies and the company licensing check limitation of their product that prevented proper identification and therefore infringement. Sure there is violation, but the elephant in the room here is that a license was available and paid for so the company producing the software had been compensated. We are not in the grey area "but I would not have bought it anyway" where "stealing" could somewhat apply.
- sbuk 11y agoNo, he stole it. He went to a website, not under CERNs jurisdiction and downloaded a cracked copy of the software thereby circumventing the license and using the software unlawfully. No pachyderms present anywhere. It really is that simple.
- gutnor 11y ago> It really is that simple. If you want to be pedantic - then no it is not that simple. The student is in license infringement, copyright violation, contract with CERN violation, ... but has not stolen anything. But yes, he need to pay for those "crimes". That's what the 30K fine is for ? Nope the 30K is just an agreed payment between the CERN and the Company for the discovery of his infringement. That money will charged back to the University thanks to another agreement and only then is going to be charged to him. The "theft" will go unpunished in the eye of the law. The student fucked up - that part is simple. Everything else that leads to him having to pay 30K is anything but simple. Considering the context described in the blog it involves a lot of bad faith from the company and the CERN.
- JupiterMoon 11y agoJust because the company and CERN say the student has to pay doesn't mean that he/she has to... The student would be well advised to call their lawyer at this juncture.
- 11y ago