8 ms·
Wow, this post makes me angry and I don't know at whom. Is it the student's fault, who wanted to use the software he had legally licensed, but couldn't because
by StavrosK 11y ago
Wow, this post makes me angry and I don't know at whom. Is it the student's fault, who wanted to use the software he had legally licensed, but couldn't because of stupid licensing terms, or the company's fault for wanting to get paid for their software?
I'm inclined to side with the student, I think. When I pay for stuff, I want to be free to use it in a reasonable manner, and restricting usage of the software on the specific computers the company likes is not reasonable.
- seivan 11y agoI might be wrong here, but from what I understood, he wanted to keep working with the simulation on his vacation? Ended up getting punished for it because of shitty license agreements. Again, I might have misunderstood.
- StavrosK 11y agoThat's my understanding as well. He had a license for the desktop but not the laptop.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 11y agoHe had a license for use while at CERN, not while off the premise.
- sbuk 11y agoHe hadn't legally licensed the software. The student is entirely at fault.
- StavrosK 11y agoThe University had given him a license, no?
- svisser 11y agoWhich the student didn't use - he used an invalid key and obtained the software using unofficial means.
- at-fates-hands 11y agoBecause the software license was restricted to use only in the lab. The student wanted to use it while he was travelling - not an unheard of use of software, and a reasonable expectation. This was OP's point. If I'm paying for a boatload of expensive licenses, why should I be limited to how and where I use the software? Makes no sense to me.
- danielweber 11y agoCERN licensed the software exactly that way. They aren't Joe Random User. They have a purchasing department that can negotiate back with the vendor.[1] Then the student wanted to override CERN's negotiation with the vendor. [1] http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/CamelsandRubberDuckies.html http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/CamelsandRubberDuckie...
- masklinn 11y agoNot the university, CERN. As the article notes CERN's license pool is only for fixed computers (not roaming), the student wanted the software on their laptop so they went and downloaded a cracked version.
- sbuk 11y agoNo. CERN were covered by a site license. FTFA; But our student failed to download AllSIM from DFS onto his office PC, since that wasn’t where he wanted to use it. He wanted to install it on his laptop so that he could work on his simulation while travelling. However, the CERN AllSIM installation would not allow for this, as roaming usage is not covered by CERN's AllSIM licence. The student had a need and was not willing to compromise i.e. by using the Windows Terminal Service. Instead, he used Google and quickly found AllSIM for free on a dubious website. Three clicks later, he was ready to go. For convenience, the student essentially stole the license.
- tomp 11y agoBut not for 30k. I doubt a court would award this much in damages if he was sued. Even before that, I don't think CERN is justified in releasing his identity (edit: I mean, the identity of the student to the software vendor for them to sue).
- seszett 11y agoHis identity has not been released.
- sbuk 11y agoThey haven't released his identity. RFTA. EDIT; I agree entirely that CHF30000 is way over the top, but if that is a negotiated figure, then he owes it.
- JupiterMoon 11y agoNope. He/she did not negotiate it. The company is speculatively invoicing CERN. CERN are attempting (with dubious legality) to pass it to a University who are attempting (with extremely dubious legality) to pass it to a student. The student should call his/her lawyer asap and should certainly not pay this demand without forcing all the parties to actually undergo some due process.
- sbuk 11y agoI think it is safe to assume that HE knowingly and wilfully breached his contract with CERN. again TFA states that, and I quote, "Understandably, the student was shocked when we investigated the case and he was forced to acknowledge the facts." The student has wilfully broken the law. Due process has clearly been undertaken. Again, RTFA.
- JupiterMoon 11y agoShe should never have acknowledged the 'facts'. She should have called her lawyer. She should also point out that she was under pressure to get stuff done and was under the impression that she had a licence to use the product. Due process implies a legal process not a random invoice and several large organisations charging an individual an arbitrary amount.
- gutnor 11y agoHe used it only under the scope of his work and the company contracting the work had the necessary seat in pool to cover for the student license. So the student is only technically at fault in the same way as you are technically trespassing when you sneaked behind your colleague that day your forgot your badge. The reason the company was able to extort ( I think that's the only appropriate term here ) 30K is because of the enormous B2B corporate administration will process this issue routinely rather than using common sense. As a European tax payer that is not the behavior of a company I want my tax money to fund.
- _Simon 11y agoNope. Read the opening paragraph again.
- dpcan 11y agoI think the only reason CERN was involved at all is because the student used an illegal version of the software to access their system. By going to CERN, they were able to track down the culprit, and that was the student, who essentially was the one who got hit with the bill.