6 ms·
How I ended up working illegally in the UK
- branchless 11y agoIt's not about LIBOR and UK banks!
- the_mitsuhiko 11y agoThe UK immigration rules are borderline bizarre at this point. I do not envy anyone not from the EU trying to immigrate into the UK. You need to earn really well and they can boot you from the country on so many grounds now, that I can see this being a challenge for many.
- _petronius 11y agoThe hassle and expense of UK immigration law was one reason I moved to Germany, even though I'd been living in London for about 8.5 years and was on track (in another three or four, with at least two further visa applications required) to get permanent residency. To be honest, I find it all a bit baffling. I know so many people who have spent inordinate amounts of time and money to study in the UK, pay international university fees (which are really expensive!), work there professionally, pay taxes there, and generally pump money into the British economy, but at every turn the Home Office seems to say "why don't you just go back to where you came from?" Surely this is going to be bad for Britain in the long run, even in the most cynical actuarial terms (to say nothing of the cultural ones)?
- the_mitsuhiko 11y ago> The hassle and expense of UK immigration law was one reason I moved to Germany When I married my wife (we both have different passports, neither of us are British) we decided to move to Austria, my country of origin because the situation in Britain looked problematic. She would have to apply to visas constantly to get into Schengen (as the UK is outside), the financial requirements for the household are sky-high (income of 18.600 GBP post taxes or access to 65.000 GBP on an account) and you would need to have that every 2.5 years. Money would not even be the problem, but the fear of this getting worse or that you might lose the job for some time really does with your brain. Especially the worry that if the UK would leave the EU, British citizenship would not help my wife either and we would again be left with different citizenships and different travel rules.
- scrollaway 11y agoThis is why I left the UK after living there 4 years. The climate went from somewhat neutral to extremely xenophobic and anti-european, very fast. Why bother staying in a country that is downright hostile to continentals? There's plenty of fantastic other countries to live in. No point wasting time with one that doesn't want filthy outsiders.
- prodmerc 11y agoWhy not apply for British citizenship? She seems to fit all the criteria... Living (semi)permanently for years in any country on a visa seems kinda foolish to me, in the end you are the citizen of another country. I know a few people who settled elsewhere in the EU and now consider themselves "citizens". Yeah, no, you're just a resident and could be kicked out or at least have a lot of issues (case in point) if politics change. Just make it really permanent by applying for citizenship if you already lived there for 10 years and intend on living there for the next 5+ years, imo...
- _petronius 11y agoApplications for citizenship (just asking, mind you, payable every time you apply, in case you have to re-apply for some reason) cost about GBP 1,000. So if ~600 quid is a kick in the teeth, 1,000 isn't any more affordable.
- prodmerc 11y agoOh, OK, that is quite expensive. But it would still settle all your worries for the future, I presume.
- _petronius 11y agoTrue. And that's one reason why if I stay in my current country of residence long enough, I'm going to naturalize, even if it means having to give up my US passport.
- the_mitsuhiko 11y ago> Why not apply for British citizenship? She seems to fit all the criteria... Not everybody is willing to adopt another citizenship just like that. First of all not everybody can have dual citizenship (I have no idea if she can, she did not say which citizen she is) secondly it comes with certain requirements. It costs money and it requires you to swear your allegiance to that country, not everybody is willing to do. It'a also expensive and you need to pass tests. Not everybody has time and money for that. > Living (semi)permanently for years in any country on a visa seems kinda foolish to me, in the end you are the citizen of another country. How so? This should be the most natural thing in the world as all countries people immigrate to have provisions that allow you to stay in the country without being a citizen. Without that many people would be much worse of as giving up citizenship can have severe punishments (expatriate taxes for instance).
- donohoe 11y agoFor background, the US is not better than the UK in many respects - both from public perception and bureaucracy/law. While I am a citizen now, I was an illegal immigrant for about 3(?) years. I worked in a bar and waited tables. One colleague in particular was very happy to complain about 'illegals', however he gave me a pass from his sweeping remarks because (as he said) "you're white and you speak English". I'd also like to point out that this guy was claiming unemployment money, not paying taxes, and likely having the gov paying in some form for his STD treatments. When I started the process for temporary work permit, green-card, then citizenship; it was no picnic either. Bureaucracy is intense (even for native English speaker). You pay out of pocket for all application fees (which is fine, but many people seem to think you're leeching on government services). I think in aggregate it amounted to about $2500. I also voluntarily payed estimated back taxes. I'm not sure this comment is helpful or informative. With the rhetoric coming out of GOP presidential candidates I just think its important for people to be reminded that the vast majority of are descended from immigrants.
- hellofunk 11y agoAll Americans are from immigrant families, except for the very few left who descended from the beautiful tribal cultures that stretch back thousands of years, and that were promptly expunged by the immigrants. No American should be complaining about modern immigrants, with the sole exception of the Native American peoples, who have the only authority to speak on the matter, yet rarely do. That speaks to the silliness of these immigrant debates.
- jdmichal 11y agoThe problem is, your argument is equally silly. Those "beautiful tribal cultures" did not spontaneously emerge; they immigrated to the Americas from Asia. So, at what point did they become "native"? Why are they native while the European-emmigrated peoples who have lived in the Americas for 3+ generations not native?
- hellofunk 11y agoI don't think you can compare the prompt disruption of American indian tribes by the arrival of Europeans over a very short time, to the thousands of years in which the "Asian immigrants" (as you suggest) became the Native Americans.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- robk 11y agoIt sucks they changed the rule retroactively. But why didn't you just get a passport? Either now or then you'd be entitled to citizenship quite easily and there's not really downside like different tax status or military service. I went ILR to citizen a few years ago and it was pretty painless.
- leoedin 11y agoI wouldn't be surprised if this is all driven by the fact the government has made campaign promises to reduce net immigration which they simply cannot meet. They're unable to control immigration from the EU, so instead they're turning up the bureaucracy and stumbling blocks on other immigration and making it much harder for recent graduates to stay and work here. It's a sad state of affairs, one which is driven by the political climate which is in turn driven by the right wing media's hate machine. It certainly doesn't make me very proud to be British.
- _petronius 11y agoI would say that is the only reasonable explanation. The US, for all of it's faults in the immigration department, really only has a bone to pick with illegal immigration. Unfortunately, in the UK, it's also the legal immigration that takes the hit. What is doubly interesting to me, is that because there are no exit checks at the border, there are no reliable statistics for net migration -- immigration minus the British (and other foreign nationals) that leave the country every year. So the panic-machine gets it's statistical fuel with every passing year, despite it not being adjusted for emigration, and all the while ignoring the measurable benefits that increased immigration is bringing with it.
- pjc50 11y agoThis is exactly it. Not only that, but quite a lot of the anti-immigrant sentiment is directed against Pakistani/Bangladeshi Muslims - who are quite often second or third generation immigrants and therefore are full British nationals. The spousal income requirement is targeted against people making arranged marriages in those communities, for example. Much of the rest of it is directed against EU nationals, who have a right to be here so long as we're in the EU. If the UK ever does leave the EU, immigration will be cited as a key reason. Moreover, we fought off an attempt at imposing national ID cards, but the government is clearly going to bring them back in by imposing them on immigrants first. (The "super premium" home visit visa service is clearly there for the benefit of the wealthy foreigners that pump the London property market and such like.)
- dudul 11y agoI don't want to come out as being insensitive, but what is the complain about exactly? I was expecting more of an anecdote due to a quirk in the law, but it ends up being a weird rant about how a change in policy somehow makes the entirety of the UK hostile to immigrants. If you're not a citizen of the country you have to expect these changes in laws and regulations. What a group of politicians puts together, another can undo. Today liberals give "free" visas to "undocumented" immigrants, tomorrow conservatives will cancel them and deport them. I am an immigrant myself and I do understand that until I fill all the criteria for citizenship I am not equal to the citizens of the country, that's just how it is. The only way to be sure that you won't have any trouble is to be a citizen.
- gambiting 11y agoYou missed the entire point of the article. You know how the banknotes say "I promise to pay the bearer on demand", which basically means that the Bank of England promises to always pay you the amount stated on the banknote,no matter how old it is? Yeah, that's basically what her visa was supposed to be - when she was issued one by the UK government the government made a promise to grant her an indefinite right to stay in the UK and not require any further permissions. Except that they did. They introduced this new mechanism for all immigrants which means that she effectively lost what was given her by the government once, even though the government promised to never take it away. That's the problem.
- dudul 11y agoBased on your comment, I did get the point because this is exactly what I was talking about. Does the visa state "this visa is irrevocable, you will never have to do anything to be allowed to stay in the country, until the end of times, ever, we promise."? Maybe it does, and then I'm happy to be wrong. In politics and legislation, there is no "promises", no "indefinite". Laws are the reflection of what society wants at a certain point in time - at least in functioning democracies. For everything, not just immigration. I'm not saying it doesn't suck. I've had my fair share of dealing with immigration regulations and I know how awful it is, but it is foolish to think that a right to residency will never be questioned and subject to different rules. Only citizenship is definite.
- rayiner 11y agoIt's worth actually reading up on the BRP. It doesn't change your visa status. Rather, it's an identification requirement. In the UK, like in the U.S., you have several ways to prove your work eligibility. One is with a passport endorsed with a Visa. Another is a biometric residence card. This woman's family let their passports expire without obtaining a BRP. There would have been no need to pay extra for expedited processing if they had not let their passport expire, or had obtained a BRP while their passports were valid. You could run into this as a citizen in the U.S. At least when I worked for the federal government, I had to show either a passport or social security card. If you let your passport expire and had lost you social security card, you couldn't work until you got a new one. Also, the whole "the application is all about terrorism" thing is bullshit. Here is the application: https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/423220/TOC_Application_Form_04.pdf https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachm.... There are three yes/no questions, in a 22-page form, about terrorism. They're next to questions about your criminal convictions, and whether you've been accused of participating in genocide.
- the_mitsuhiko 11y ago> One is with a passport endorsed with a Visa. Another is a biometric residence card. This woman's family let their passports expire without obtaining a BRP You left out that this is new since April 2015. //EDIT: this is how other european countries do it. You get this card which lives independent of your passport: http://www.aupair-worldwide.de/_gfx/news/246_1.jpg http://www.aupair-worldwide.de/_gfx/news/246_1.jpg
- rayiner 11y agoThey've been issuing them since at least 2013: https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/261497/brp-information-leaflet.pdf https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachm....
- the_mitsuhiko 11y agoSeems like the issue there is that these are replacing the old system and now people start to demand them.
- rwmj 11y agoI don't think this article is correct. Some workplaces are demanding BRP because it's a way to shield themselves from liability and large fines if they accidentally employ an "illegal immigrant", but it's not actually necessary (yet - I'm sure it'll be made mandatory at some point in order to provide yet more revenue and pointless bureaucracy). If you are self-employed you can still just use ILR even in an expired passport. It's right that the whole situation is opaque, expensive and stupid.
- lilula 11y agoOriginal author of the article here. I will answer questions to the best of my knowledge. Please be nice. The BRP was enacted earlier this year. I have had two passports since my ILR visa was issued (it's currently affixed in an old passport). So I do have a current passport, it's just that the visa is in an old one. I do qualify for citizenship, and it did cross my mind. But it's quite expensive for me. And to add insult to injury, I would still need the BRP (£1000~ citizenship + £660 BRP). For me that's not an amount I have readily available. Maybe I took my visa for granted, but I was awarded it when I was a teenager. I called up immigration a few years back, and asked about whether I should get my visa transferred to a newer passport, or whether I should apply for a citizenship, and was told that unless I really wanted to vote then I shouldn't worry about it (the only thing denied to residents with an ILR, apparently). It just didn't occur to me that one of my responsibilities (?) would be to keep up with current immigration legislation, just in case the rights I was initially awarded indefinitely would suddenly be changed in a way which is disruptive to my life. It kind of scares me to think that things like this can be changed on a whim. I don't really know what to think.
- lilula 11y agoAlso I'm an American citizen, since some people were asking.
- dudul 11y ago>It just didn't occur to me that one of my responsibilities (?) would be to keep up with current immigration legislation Unfortunately, you do have to do that. As a green card holder, I try to keep in touch with any potential changes in legislation. Incredibly boring since most often nothing new, but for example the Patriot Act added a bunch of new requirements for non-citizens. >just in case the rights I was initially awarded indefinitely would suddenly be changed in a way which is disruptive to my life. This can happen, and is not limited to immigration. Someone can build a business and face issues years later when the government adds new regulations. Couples adopt kids from abroad and then see the rules change and face a lot of troubles (happened to one of my friends who adopted from Russia). Laws change.
- ktzar 11y ago
- lucaspiller 11y agoAs a UK citizen (but no longer resident) it really baffles me how expensive and complicated it is to get documentation from the government for seemingly common place things. Last year I had my passport stolen while I was travelling in Italy. Getting a passport issued when you are living outside the UK can take months, so I decided to go back to my parents. As the UK is outside the schengen-area I wasn't able to travel there without a passport, so had to book an appointment at the British Consulate in Milano. Three days later I turned up and they issued me an 'Emergency Passport', this is pretty much the same as a normal passport except smaller as it is for a single trip, and costs £95 [0]. When I got back to the UK I booked an appointment, the earliest they had was 4 weeks later (you can't get a replacement for a lost or stolen passport under the 1-day service). On the day I travelled up to London (~£50 by train), paid another £103, came home and waited a week for it to be delivered. Earlier this year I got married (outside the UK and my current home country) and needed to get a "Certificate of no impediment" to say I am legally able to get married. On the gov.uk website it says I can do this at the consulate nearest to where I live, but they said I needed to do it at the consulate nearest to where I intended to get married. So off I went there, handed in the form and paid the £65 fee. This then got displayed somewhere for a week so people can oppose it if needed (not that anyone in this country knew me...), and then I went back, paid another £65 and got the certificate. I also needed to get my birth certificate legalised - which can only be done by sending it back to the UK... [0] In the local currency at a rather poor exchange rate.
- easytiger 11y agoThe UK is also one of the most heavily taxed countries in the world. The government are happy to gouge you and it is getting worse almost by the month at present.
- valdiorn 11y agoHaving moved from Scandinavia to the UK, I can tell you, ther tax rate there is quite comfortable :) Enjoying my six figure salary and a rougly 34% tax rate (incl. National insurance). ... I am more used to 42-45%.
- koyote 11y agoAccording to the government's own site, people on ILR without a BRP do not need one at any time unless they are moving their visa to a different passport [1]. I also do not see any mention of it needed to get employment [2]. Having dealt with UK employment law indirectly I can see how your brother's (and subsequently your) employer might have gotten confused about the rules as they are not very clear (which just goes to show what a mess immigration law here is). That being said, the whole system is unnecessarily expensive, bureaucratic and confusing. I am not sure how that necessarily makes it directly xenophobic though (there are many other government procedures that have a similar unnecessary complexity). [1]https://www.gov.uk/biometric-residence-permits https://www.gov.uk/biometric-residence-permits [2]https://www.gov.uk/check-job-applicant-right-to-work https://www.gov.uk/check-job-applicant-right-to-work