4 ms·
I've searched a little, found "Myths Of Genetically Modified Seeds, Busted," obviously something that can be considered a pro-GMO article for the way how the sp
by acqq 11y ago
I've searched a little, found "Myths Of Genetically Modified Seeds, Busted," obviously something that can be considered a pro-GMO article for the way how the specific "myth" is formulated, but it's good enough to find out what's being claimed:
http://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2012/10/18/163034053/top-five-myths-of-genetically-modified-seeds-busted http://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2012/10/18/163034053/top...
In short, if the farmer would select only the plants that survive the herbicide (effectively only those that over cross-pollination get "Monsanto" genes), they could sue him, and they did sue Schmeiser (and the farmer would probably lose as in the given example "The Canadian Supreme Court ruled that Schmeiser had violated Monsanto's patent" and the farmer lost).
But if the farmer has just the "trace amounts of GMOs" in his crops they wouldn't (and they "will pay to remove any of its GMOs from fields where they don't belong."(!))
The myth as stated in the article is "Monsanto will sue you for growing their patented GMOs if traces of those GMOs entered your fields through wind-blown pollen." Note "traces". Only that is a myth.
But that they sue when somebody sows the seeds with the genes from their seed that he hasn't bought from them, even if he obtained them by cross-pollination, it happened, they sued, and they won the case.
- secabeen 11y agoSo it takes an active step by the farmer who is sowing seeds he/she has reason to know are protected.
- acqq 11y agoThe "active" step is simply keeping the seeds from the plants you sowed on your land with your own seeds that survived the herbicides. Schmeiser claims that he was doing breeding of his own seeds for 50 years. Why shouldn't he?
- vectorjohn 11y agoOk, yes they will sue when a farmer willingly and deliberately uses cross pollinate seeds. I see nothing controversial there though.
- acqq 11y agoIt is controversial as the farmer was actually doing breeding himself 50 years using his own seeds. His actions were the actions of the breeder. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Percy_Schmeiser#Monsanto_v._Schmeiser https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Percy_Schmeiser#Monsanto_v._Sc... "In 1997, Percy Schmeiser found Monsanto's genetically modified “Roundup Ready Canola” plants growing near his farm. He testified that he sprayed his nearby field and found that much of the crop survived, meaning it was also Roundup Ready.[2] He testified that he then harvested that crop, saved it separately from his other harvest, and intentionally planted it in 1998.[2] Monsanto approached him to pay a license fee for using Monsanto's patented technology without a license. Schmeiser refused, claiming that the actual seed was his because it was grown on his land, and so Monsanto sued Schmeiser for patent infringement on August 6, 1998.[2]" Nobody disputes that it was a case of cross-pollination. He was sued for keeping the results of that cross-pollination. Why shouldn't he if he didn't use the seeds from Monsanto but his own?
- vectorjohn 11y agoBecause the seeds weren't his own anymore. What, you think he believes he bred a roundup ready crop? That's why he lost the case, he definitely knew what he was doing.
- acqq 11y agoHow come the seeds aren't his own? The complete genetic structure of his seeds is certainly different to the Monsanto ones. It's just that the one allele got transferred via cross-pollination and remained in his own seeds he preserved, giving the seeds one specific property which is the same as in the Monsanto seeds. Breeding is selecting your own seeds based on their properties, and Schmeiser was a breeder.
- bmelton 11y agoUnless I'm missing something from your citation, he wasn't sued. He was the suer, and he won. I don't see what's controversial about that. Edit: I see that the other suit[1] was not cited. In the Monsanto v. Schmeizer suit, he was accidentally planting Monsanto seeds that he had harvested, and did not mount a sufficient defense against it. "Schmeiser supporters argued that his account still leaves open the possibility that the harvesting and replanting of Roundup Ready canola from the sprayed region was accidental and resulted from a miscommunication between Schmeiser and his farmhand, or from a failure of Schmeiser to have the presence of mind to instruct his farmhand to avoid taking canola seed for replanting from the sprayed region." He knowingly used Monsanto seeds in his crops, but thought that using the seeds would not be theft because he didn't apply RoundUp to them. That's like suggesting that if I steal a Tesla roadster, but convert it to a gasoline engine, then I haven't stolen it. Again though, I don't see this as terribly controversial, unless I'm missing something. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monsanto_Canada_Inc_v_Schmeiser https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monsanto_Canada_Inc_v_Schmeise...