6 ms·
I am reminded of a comment made about the Melissa virus [1]: While the Melissa license is a bit unclear, Melissa aggressively encourages free distribut
by jerf 11y ago
I am reminded of a comment made about the Melissa virus [1]:
While the Melissa license is a bit unclear, Melissa aggressively
encourages free distribution of its source code.
While the license on genes is a bit unclear, they aggressively encourage free distribution of their source code. How are we going to prevent the Chinese from standing downwind of a farm plot and catching pollen for analysis? (I say "Chinese" only because that's what the story happens to be about... it applies to anyone, of course.) Or sequencing them through mundane means in the US and transmitting the gene code back to China?
Physically preventing people from "stealing" your genes is impossible in the long term. Only legal protection can work, and that is probably questionable in the long term too.
[1]: https://lists.debian.org/debian-devel/1999/04/msg00292.html https://lists.debian.org/debian-devel/1999/04/msg00292.html
- acqq 11y agoThe article states the apparent agenda at its end: "The intent of the U.S. government to use food as an ever-more powerful point of leverage to wield over large, increasingly hungry nations like China. The prosecution of Mo Hailong and his circle stands as a warning to the Chinese government, issued through its proxy companies. The ears in the field, the seeds in the ground, even the pollen on the wind, are American-owned and American-protected. They are available to the world as food only if you agree to our conditions and are willing to pay our price." And the US, as the only superpower (1) has many ways of making other nations to comply. One nice example, related to the GM food and the EU opposition of it, can be extrapolated from the links: June 2003: http://www.theguardian.com/science/2003/jun/24/gm.food http://www.theguardian.com/science/2003/jun/24/gm.food "Mr Bush's comments came barely a month after his administration took Europe's ban on GM crops to the World Trade Organisation, saying the moratorium was a barrier to trade." Just a little later: http://www.theguardian.com/science/2003/jul/02/gm.food2 http://www.theguardian.com/science/2003/jul/02/gm.food2 "The European parliament today lifted the ban on genetically modified foods, instead choosing to impose a strict labelling regime that could stave off a trade war with the US." ------ 1) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Potential_superpowers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Potential_superpowers
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- giltleaf 11y agoNot to mention all that is going on with TTIP now; essentially, trade officials are saying that working through GE crop related non-tariff barriers to trade is what the whole deal hinges on (ie. consumers are against it in EU and ag biz lobby is trying to ram it down their throats from over here. I would mention, as its a common misconception, that it's legal to sell GE crops in the EU, they just did so terribly that they've been pulled from shelves- Consumers exercised a preference and the market dictates). For some more info (pdf from Center For Food Safety): http://www.centerforfoodsafety.org/files/trade_matters_10_14_19123.pdf http://www.centerforfoodsafety.org/files/trade_matters_10_14... Here is the link to the page linking to the pdf http://www.centerforfoodsafety.org/reports/3152/trade-matters-transatlantic-trade-and-investment-partnership-ttip--impacts-on-food-and-farming http://www.centerforfoodsafety.org/reports/3152/trade-matter...
- jessaustin 11y agoThat is a fascinating, high-quality wikipedia page. I didn't know that sort of article existed, but it is a credit to the editors.
- 2close4comfort 11y agoThis has been done for years domestically Farmers have been driven to bankruptcy by Monsanto, Pioneer etc for simply having fields where cross-contamination occurred. Now all that is happening is this idea is being enforced internationally...too bad. I had hoped people outside the US would force us to realize this error.
- vectorjohn 11y agoThis hasn't happened, or you need a citation please.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ethbro 11y ago(This comment is going to get me so much hate, but match to kindling...) Monsanto, DuPont Pioneer, Syngenta et al. are easy boogeymen. So are pharmaceutical companies. I mean, they're just like the *AA, trying to create artificial scarcity through draconian IP laws, no? No. You may argue about compensation, and whether they're using unfair market tactics or taking an excessive share of the profits created by their products. But when you boil it down, these companies are burning incredible amounts of money (and talent) to fuel R&D engines that are literally keeping humans alive. Look at Monsanto's research pipeline: http://www.monsanto.com/products/pages/research-development-pipeline.aspx http://www.monsanto.com/products/pages/research-development-... http://www.monsanto.com/investors/documents/2015/2015.01.07_mon-q1f15-rd-update-presentation.pdf http://www.monsanto.com/investors/documents/2015/2015.01.07_... Those profits aren't just being pissed into the wind. These are extremely competitive industries, doing cutting edge science, with the goal of feeding and/or healing humans. How downright evil of them. I'm probably just as suspicious about GMOs as the next guy, but I've yet to hear any of the anti-GMO / anti-Big-Ag crowd propose a feasible solution for how we're going to keep pace with a ballooning world population. Farm to table or heritage variants don't feed the world. And it's just not cheap to (a) make something useful & (b) make sure it doesn't kill anyone. If you think Big Ag is a problem, try imagining what a world with steadily declining food security looks like in terms of stability. End result? Yes, protecting the golden goose so that it can keep laying eggs merits some extraordinary protections. Although, like everything else, I'm perfectly willing to debate on whether those are not-enough, just-right, or too-far. But I don't see how "none" gives us a very nice future.
- e40 11y agothese companies are burning incredible amounts of money (and talent) to fuel R&D engines that are literally keeping humans alive. And, according to another FPP today[1], they're bilking us for a lot of these "wonder" drugs. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10080680 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10080680
- refurb 11y agoYou're confusing clinical trials with FDA approved drugs. The FDA already has regulations in place to prevent the kind of abuse of statistics seen in that thread.
- hibikir 11y agoSequencing doesn't matter. It's getting the inbreds that matter. It's all in the article, but probably not so clear if you lack the background. Getting a bag of GMO corn seed is not difficult. But reproducing said seed to the same level of quality is going to take you many years. It's a bit like trying to get a clone of yourself by having children with women: The kids will be a lot like you genetically, but it'll take you forever to make a clone. So how do agricultural companies do this? By building special inbred varieties that have he same genotype as phenotype. All the offspring of crossing any specific pair of inbreds will be identical, and those are the offspring that you can buy at the store. The inbreds, who are also worse performing in the field, not so much: They are seen as trade secrets, and the companies just use them for research and manufacturing. So it's not really about hiding the genetics of something you sell, or even hiding the genetics of something you use to create what you sell(which would still have some value, but still), but protecting the seeds of specific plants that are necessary to the manufacturing process. If you give some corn breeders an entire bag of hybrid corn, and tell them to produce 1000 bags just like it, they'll ask you to come back in a decade or two. If you give them a bag of each of the inbreds that were use to make it,they will have the 1000 bags in a season. That's what agricultural companies try to protect.
- stephengillie 11y agoYou make these inbred parent seeds sound like private keys in encryption. You jealously guard them, you combine them to create offspring (public keys) which you freely distribute without worry, and lots of people are trying some arcane process to deduce your exact secret.
- btown 11y agoI think you mean public keys in the second sentence, but if so, that sounds like a very apt analogy.
- stephengillie 11y agoYes I did, and thank you.
- aaron695 11y ago> Physically preventing people from "stealing" your genes is impossible in the long term. You can't stop people from doing anything, it's always about slowing them down and making it hard right? 5 minutes on the lock on your door might mean a non broken in house. A day or two on the net for software or media might equal hundreds of thousands of dollars. A month or two for genes might equal billions.