4 ms·
A good rule of thumb for evaluating the merit of groups (political factions, interest groups, whatever) is whether or not they encourage critical thinking (educ
by dsfyu404ed 11y ago
A good rule of thumb for evaluating the merit of groups (political factions, interest groups, whatever) is whether or not they encourage critical thinking (education).
- SiVal 11y agoBy that measure, "education" includes many of the worst offenders. The most intensely political of the departments on campus tend to be the ones who talk most about "critical thinking". The loudest proponents of "critical thinking" tend to be the most ideologically monocultural. They tend to be the most adamant supporters of "speech codes" designed to silence their critics. They tend to be ones who most closely scrutinize others for ever smaller deviations ("micro aggression! he used the wrong word!") from the enforced, orthodox dogma before going back to class to teach their students about "critical thinking". The Marxist "English" professor who tells you that what she wants most from your paper is "evidence of critical thinking" means she will judge your paper on how persuasively it argues in favor of her political agenda. Real-world evidence that casts doubt on Marxist theory will most likely be punished and labeled "lack of critical thinking". The social justice warriors in the ed school go on endlessly about their commitment to "critical thinking" and its supposed superiority to "mere facts", yet nobody in electrical engineering ever uses the term, "mere facts". Nobody in the physics department who is trying to make sense of puzzling data from some space probe ever consults the critical thinkers in the ed school to get the benefit of their better-trained reasoning powers. When Larry Summers, president of Harvard, suggested that a natural, statistical phenomenon (fatter right tail due to greater variance, not higher mean) might be a major reason for more male than female math professors, he lost his job. In attempting to defend himself, he clearly felt that evidence of his political conformity ("I'm a lifelong liberal with a long record of...") mattered more to the decision makers than empirical evidence of the phenomenon. If the top leadership at Harvard, arguably the world's leading educational institution, believes that other top leadership at Harvard is more persuaded by argument from political identity than argument from empirical evidence, what is it they are really promoting when they so vociferously promote "critical thinking"?
- danharaj 11y agoDo you honestly not understand why it is problematic for the president of Harvard to try to explain away a political issue he is in charge of and has no business trying to explain away? I am also amused how salty you are about leftist academics when the very same argument (which isn't very substantial and mostly tiresome) could be rephrased as an assault on economics, which gleefully assume ridiculous things about societies in order to prove liberal or right wing ideas that also happen to be allied to power. But no, economics is completey apolitical right? Larry Summers was being completely apolitical and acting appropriately in his role as president of Harvard in making that remark. The reason why he came under fire is clear to me, but it's not clear to you. I don't think I could explain it to you. Your post drips with contempt for a certain class of people you do not name but characterize in the same way other unsavory ideologues do. > yet nobody in electrical engineering ever uses the term That's probably because electrical engineering is enormously easier to understand than more complicated disciplines. > Nobody in the physics department who is trying to make sense of puzzling data from some space probe ever consults the critical thinkers in the ed school to get the benefit of their better-trained reasoning powers. And yet the theoretical physicists who try to push the boundaries of what we understand to be possible quite often employ thinking that has a deep relationship with the processes that underlie more philosophical disciplines. Not all of life or even science is reading bits streaming in from the outer solar system. And before my ability to perform quantitative or critical reasoning is impugned, I majored in mathematics and ended up in a discipline that hasn't quite been hammered down the way, say EE has been. Somehow I survived such an education without becoming so mean-spirited towards people who study far more difficult ideas than spinors and circuit diagrams. > In attempting to defend himself, he clearly felt that evidence of his political conformity ("I'm a lifelong liberal with a long record of...") mattered more to the decision makers than empirical evidence of the phenomenon. If the top leadership at Harvard, arguably the world's leading educational institution, believes that other top leadership at Harvard is more persuaded by argument from political identity than argument from empirical evidence, what is it they are really promoting when they so vociferously promote "critical thinking"? Maybe he's not so good at thinking his way out of putting his shoe in his mouth. Authority does not make you good at everything. Neither does prestige in one particular field.