3 ms·
(here's my $0.02 in no particular order) "Interestingly, the researchers tracked the same students into the sophomore physics course that a third of the freshm
by dsfyu404ed 11y ago
(here's my $0.02 in no particular order)
"Interestingly, the researchers tracked the same students into the sophomore physics course that a third of the freshmen had advanced into. Even there, they still saw improvements, despite the fact that none of the critical thinking instructions were repeated in that course."
I think "Interestingly" should have been "predictably."
A mechanical engineer, lawyer, physicist and EMT encounter a dilapidated stairwell railing and all have very different thoughts about it. People everything through the lens of the intelligence they've acquired throughout their lives.
"Critical thinking" just makes a better buzzword than "applying stuff that's been learned in different contexts".
Physics to physics is a pretty low hanging fruit for studying this kind of effect (which isn't a bad thing). Math to physics or economics to history would be a more interesting point to study. For example, the history of North America from 1600-1700 is much more interesting to study if you know about the economics of Europe at the time which itself is much more interesting if you know that chunk of European history. Knowing physics makes studying basic calculus much more interesting and beneficial and vise-versa .
- tbabb 11y ago"Critical thinking" is a term with more specific meaning than just "apply what you know". Critical thinking means asking yourself how you know what you think you know, mistrusting casual intuition, and examining how your own thinking process could lead you to a wrong conclusion.
- rcthompson 11y agoIt is a low bar, but it's still one that is not consistently hurdled by most education programs. So many students just want to get their A grades and then purge the entire semester from their memories. (Or maybe they don't explicitly want this, but it's what they get by cramming instead of learning.)