4 ms·
Well, to be sure, if the definition of 'clearly stated' is made to exclude counterexamples to the assertion, then there are no counterexamples. :-) I don't th
by JadeNB 11y ago
Well, to be sure, if the definition of 'clearly stated' is made to exclude counterexamples to the assertion, then there are no counterexamples. :-) I don't think many people would include 'not self referential' in the definition of 'clearly stated'; for example, "is this question more than eight words long?" is pretty clear.
- MrManatee 11y agoTo put my words in context, I was thinking about mathematical questions, such as "does there exist a curve that goes through every point in a square?". Everyone has some kind of intuitive understanding of what's a "curve", but mathematicians need a precise definition in order to make this question clear enough for mathematical study. (There is such a curve: the Hilbert curve.) It's not at all easy to recognize when a question is stated "clearly enough", and your questions provide an excellent example of this. The question "is this question more than eight words long?" refers to question itself (as a string), and in general, this kind of self-reference is perfectly harmless. The question "Is the answer to this question 'no'?" refers to its own answer, and this kind of self-reference is potentially problematic.