3 ms·
> For instance, in those cases in which Smart City has used de-authentication in the past, it targeted only access points and wireless devices that are located
by Someone1234 11y ago
> For instance, in those cases in which Smart City has used de-authentication in the past, it targeted only access points and wireless devices that are located within the confined and proprietary space of the exhibit hall -- areas of a convention center that are licensed for private event and to which access is limited -- and that pose a threat to secure, reliable, WiFi availability within that confined space.
That's not how WiFi works. They cannot know for a fact that these WiFi hotspots are within the convention space, they could and likely are, blocking WiFi located outside of that space.
Additionally they're claiming that they literally own the radio spectrum within a "proprietary space" which is a dangerous line. What is stopping them from blocking all cellular signals or worse charging cellphone companies for the signal travelling through their space?
Their point about security is nonsense. The technology they're employing is DESIGNED to secure WiFi networks by disconnecting actually rogue APs (i.e. devices squawking the same SSID as their network), that is still legal, the problem they and the Hilten ran into is that they took tech' designed for security and mis-used it for monopolising the WiFi spectrum within their convention centers.
So, sorry, no. If your WiFi network is called SmartCityWiFi and you disconnect MyHotSpot then you're breaking the law and have zero security arguments to make.
Good on the FCC for giving these guys a fine. Too bad it wasn't more. I read their arguments and it has only made me side with the FCC more. What they're asking for would make the world a worse place in general and only helps their bottom line.
- notacoward 11y ago> They cannot know for a fact that these WiFi hotspots are within the convention space You don't think triangulation can be that accurate? > they could and likely are, blocking WiFi located outside of that space. You have even less basis for that statement than they had for theirs. > They're claiming that they literally own the radio spectrum within a "proprietary space" which is a dangerous line. Absolutely agree. That's why we need to have those conversations, instead of just oversimplifying into "bad guys" trying to meet their SLAs and "good guys" bringing whatever gadgets they want to the party. > If your WiFi network is called SmartCityWiFi and you disconnect MyHotSpot then you're breaking the law [citation needed] > Good on the FCC for giving these guys a fine I agree. In my opinion spoofing de-auth packets should be legally equivalent to jamming (currently it's not) and should be severely punished. The fine was deserved. On the other hand, let's not rush to throw the baby out with the bathwater. There is a serious issue here, which won't go away until we face it.
- Someone1234 11y ago> You don't think triangulation can be that accurate? Does Cisco's anti-rogue AP tech perform triangulation? Why would it when it isn't designed to limit what people can do in physical spaces? > You have even less basis for that statement than they had for theirs. I know how the tech works. I know how the anti-rogue AP tech works. I have plenty of reasons for believing that they're disconnecting APs outside of a physical zone (since it isn't designed to do accomplish that to begin with). >> If your WiFi network is called SmartCityWiFi and you disconnect MyHotSpot then you're breaking the law > [citation needed] Literally the article this entire thread is about... The FCC's fine of Smart City today that we're discussing is the citation. I cannot believe you even asked for that... Wow.
- notacoward 11y ago> Literally the article this entire thread is about As another commenter so politely put it, and received no censure, absolutely wrong. You're trying to make a distinction based on SSIDs, and SSIDs have no legal standing. The string "SSID" doesn't even appear in the FCC's decision. Reasonable people can disagree on whether this was the right decision, and as it happens we do agree. Reasonable people can disagree on which statutes, definitions, etc. apply. However, reasonable people can not claim that the entire thread is about SSIDs. To quote you, "Wow."
- Someone1234 11y agoThat's a strawman, the term "SSID" appearing or not appearing is irrelevant. The distinction is about legal and illegal usage of rogue AP containment. To quote Cisco[0]: > Rogue AP-connected clients, or rogue ad hoc connected clients, may be contained by sending 802.11 de-authentication packets from local APs. This should be done only after steps have been taken to ensure that the AP is truly a rogue AP, because it is illegal to do this to a legitimate AP in a neighboring WLAN. This is the reason why Cisco removed the automatic rogue AP containment feature from this solution. You're arguing that it is illegal in all circumstances, Cisco disagrees. The FCC also has not brought a single enforcement action against anyone utilising rogue AP containment the way it was designed, they have only brought it against businesses using it to shut down third party WiFi (that wasn't pretending to belong to the same network). [0] https://supportforums.cisco.com/document/143301/rogue-access-point-location-and-containment https://supportforums.cisco.com/document/143301/rogue-access...
- xenadu02 11y agoBingo. You are totally and 100% legitimately allowed to hijack, block, and/or de-auth rogue WiFi access points broadcasting the same SSID as you so long as the blocking is targeted at your own property (some leakage is inevitable). If attendees were naming their personal hotspots "SmartCity" then SmartCity would have a point. They weren't.
- notacoward 11y agoIn the first paragraph you mention property, but SSIDs aren't property. They don't own "SmartCity" and you don't own "RandomPundit" and I don't own "DidMyResearch" either. The legal point seems to be whether Smart City's actions were limited to the physical space they owned or leased, not what SSIDs were involved.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoYeah, I'm not seeing any evidence that they were the first to be using a particular SSID when they shut them down. What happens if we both have the same SSID and move into the same area? Who 'owns' that SSID? Smart City gets to just roll into town taking over any SSID it wants?
- notacoward 11y agoAs far as I can tell, strongest signal wins (assuming it's within transmit-power limits). Probably just as well, since adjudicating disputes over who owns what SSID in what space would be a total nightmare.
- nickodell 11y ago>They don't own "SmartCity" They have a trademark on the phrase "Smart City Networks" within the area of wireless high-speed Internet. http://tmsearch.uspto.gov/bin/showfield?f=doc&state=4801:lwav4n.2.1 http://tmsearch.uspto.gov/bin/showfield?f=doc&state=4801:lwa...
- BobLaw 11y ago
- Lan 11y ago>That's not how WiFi works. They cannot know for a fact that these WiFi hotspots are within the convention space, they could and likely are, blocking WiFi located outside of that space. To play devil's advocate, some APs support rogue triangulation. Ours plot any rogues on a building map so we know exactly where they are. When combined with a proper wireless survey, you could ensure that they don't deauth anything beyond the building perimeter. Not that I recommend that, since at the very least someone should be able to tether their phone if they want. But also because it puts additional overhead on your APs, which are usually already taxed in high-usage areas.
- Lawtonfogle 11y ago>that is still legal, the problem they and the Hilten ran into is that they took tech' designed for security and mis-used it for monopolising the WiFi spectrum within their convention centers. Why is this legal while the other practice is not? Say the conference center uses a wifi named HallWifi. Why are they allowed to block me from using the same SSID but not HallWifi2 or else? Also, what about blocking similar SSIDs like Hal1Wifi? This seems one of those things where you have to write a 'I can't define exactly what is illegal, but I know it when I see it' law. I really don't like those types of laws.
- nickodell 11y ago>What is stopping them from blocking all cellular signals or worse charging cellphone companies for the signal travelling through their space? Cell phones use licensed spectrum. If you want to operate a jammer, you're going to need permission from Sprint, which they're not going to give you. Now, if Sprint wants to operate a cellphone tower on your property, then you can charge them out the nose.