3 ms·
"We continue to teach our kids French but we don't teach them Ruby On Rails. Which do you think will help them more in the coming years?" Asked that way, I'm n
by tokenadult 17y ago
"We continue to teach our kids French but we don't teach them Ruby On Rails. Which do you think will help them more in the coming years?"
Asked that way, I'm not so sure the question has a definite answer. French will still be French by the time today's middle school students graduate from college, but Ruby on Rails just might be old-fashioned technology by then. And maybe the paradigm of programming in general will have changed by then more than any modern language has changed. I'm not disparaging computer science as a subject of study--in fact my oldest son did learn more computer science in middle school (mostly C through the Eric Roberts texts used by the EPGY distance learning program
http://epgy.stanford.edu/courses/cs/ http://epgy.stanford.edu/courses/cs/
but also Logo) but foreign language study is important too. As another article submitted in the last few hours points out, schools don't teach nearly enough mathematics these days, either, so the whole curriculum has to become more efficient to squeeze in one more subject.
I homeschool my children to have more flexibility to choose better curricular materials and to have efficiency in teaching so that my children devote the most time to the subjects they NEED the most time for. That allows them to learn programming at middle school age while also being bilingual and well practiced in writing and mathematical problem-solving.
- dagw 17y agoI've 'lost' more potential jobs due to not being able to speak French than not knowing Ruby. Also I'm pretty sure I can become competent in ruby on rails a lot faster than I can become competent in French.
- xal 17y agoCompetent, sure. However you can learn a spoken language much faster then people imagine. You could have conversations in french by christmas next year with some basic courses, a good software, some tenacity and a 2 week vacation.
- tjr 17y agoI started learning BASIC on an Apple IIe in 5th grade when a couple of other students and I figured out that we could write programs on the computer. We were taught a bit of Logo in a 5th grade class, but mostly we just learned on our own, staying in at recess and writing programs at home. (We were blessed with parents who bought Apple IIe machines as well.) I don't remember the last time I touched a line of Apple IIe BASIC; it was probably around 6th grade. Later, I learned C, and then moved on to a variety of other languages. The learning of BASIC per se wasn't particularly useful, but the fact that I learned to program at all was very useful. I'm not convinced that the long-term viability of the language (or even the particular programming paradigm) is very relevant. It was writing poorly-understood BASIC code that got me into programming, and without that start, I probably wouldn't be writing programs of any sort today.
- arethuza 17y agoThat is a false dichotomy - kids should learn languages and get some exposure to a decent programming languages. As far as I am concerned, I'd like to read Proust (and Schiller) in the original languages but I'm not aware of anything in Ruby that I'm so keen to read.