4 ms·
Why is it that anytime LibreOffice or OpenOffice is discussed, it takes about 3 comments before somebody starts talking about Microsoft's ribbon interface? How
by criddell 11y ago
Why is it that anytime LibreOffice or OpenOffice is discussed, it takes about 3 comments before somebody starts talking about Microsoft's ribbon interface? How is it still a contentious subject?
I think I probably read those comment threads because it makes me feel like some kind of genius. I have the seemingly rare ability to use either the LibreOffice menu+toolbar interface or the Office ribbon interface.
That said, I don't like using LibreOffice because it's ugly (IMHO of course) and beautiful things work better.
- jmulho 11y agoCount the number of widgets used in the top two inches of screen real estate. If it is greater than say 10, that isn't beautiful; not for someone trying to figure out how to use it.
- cwyers 11y agoLibreOffice is ugly, but a fair amount of the ugliness comes from the effort to shoehorn more and more features into the same style of UI design that inspired Microsoft to develop the Ribbon UI to begin with. Yes, I suppose it's possible that LibreOffice could come up with their own, more modern UI. But I doubt it. UI design has never been a strength of theirs, and the Ribbon UI comes from an incredible amount of research at Microsoft that costs rather a lot of money to do. So the question of which style of Office UI to use is eternally a question - people who hate the Ribbon will insist on holding out, but it makes LibreOffice look more and more dated the longer they do.
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoSome of the ugliness came from implementation decisions that LibreOffice have been busy fixing. For example the dialogues used to have to be laid out in such a way that all languages strings would fit in the space that was left. Which left them a bit sparse and odd looking. I think that conversion is all done now: https://wiki.documentfoundation.org/Development/WidgetLayout https://wiki.documentfoundation.org/Development/WidgetLayout
- criddell 11y agoWow - what a difference that makes. It's very encouraging to see visuals getting some attention.
- krylon 11y agoIt would have been nice if Microsoft had at least made the ribbon bar optional and allowed people to revert to the old interface. The whole debate would disappear if you could choose the UI you prefer and be done with it. That being said, I was mildly surprised that most people I have spoken to about this seemed to like the ribbon bar, especially non-techies (who are, after all, the main audience for MS Office).
- scholia 11y agoThere's a cost to maintaining old interfaces, and the old UI had only one advantage: some people already knew it well and weren't prepared to change. However, they could still use their old version of Office, simply by not upgrading. > most people I have spoken to about this seemed to like the ribbon bar, especially non-techies I'm a techie and I love it. The old UI now looks incredibly clunky. What really surprises me is that some people are still thinking about a change that occurred in 2007 ;-)
- xixi77 11y agoadmittedly, the new ribbon interface (well I guess it's no longer new, it's just that I went from using excel for about 6hrs/day to maybe 12hrs/year circa 2005) does look prettier -- but how do people actually go about finding anything in it? does everyone just use google & try to find some blog post with screenshots?
- dragonwriter 11y ago> but how do people actually go about finding anything in it? The discoverability is pretty much the same as the old pull-downs and toolbar approach (and how you find things is pretty much the same -- click on the category whose label seems like what you might, and then look through whats revealed by that), but consolidated into what amounts to a set of toolbars organized into tabs, rather than a combination of toolbars and menus. (And what often gets ignores is that a lot of the improvements have been in the contextual right-click pop-up, which means what you usually need often doesn't require using the ribbon at all.) > does everyone just use google & try to find some blog post with screenshots? No more so than with the old interface.
- Spooky23 11y agoAll of the Openoffice/LibreOffice folks that I know are generally very.... passionate about the ribbon.
- buovjaga 11y agoMy understanding is that ribbon was not considered for LibO due to the patent controversy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ribbon_%28computing%29#Patent_controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ribbon_%28computing%29#Patent_... The design team is focusing on improving the sidebar. It does make sense as the typical displays now have much more screen estate in the x axis. Calligra is another office suite with a sidebar. Btw. the team is always looking for new contributors: https://wiki.documentfoundation.org/Design/Team https://wiki.documentfoundation.org/Design/Team
- krylon 11y agoI would not say that LibreOffice/OpenOffice is ugly. It is not very pretty, but I think that is okay - I use it to get work done. I can live with ribbon interfaces, but I still think they were a bad idea, made all the more annoying by everyone and their grandma jumping on that particular train. But, for better or worse, it is a little late for this discussion.
- tankenmate 11y ago"beautiful things work better" Beautiful things appear to work better; less cognitive dissonance. The world of project management is replete with instances of software being replaced by something that looks better only to find that it doesn't actually work better (and the converse as well). In the world of the arts truth and beauty are typically correlated, other realms of human endeavour less so.
- cwyers 11y agoIt really helps out in life in general if one assumes that the author meant "all else being equal" unless the author explicitly contradicts it.