3 ms·
This article is waaaay off base. First of all, NASA is trying to get into faster launch cycles, that's the entire point of the whole reusable rocket projects.
by moron4hire 17y ago
This article is waaaay off base. First of all, NASA is trying to get into faster launch cycles, that's the entire point of the whole reusable rocket projects. Second, nobody can complain with the shuttle software defect rate: the last 11 versions had a total of 17 defects (http://www.fastcompany.com/magazine/06/writestuff.html http://www.fastcompany.com/magazine/06/writestuff.html). Seventeen. If anything, the rest of the world could learn a lesson from NASA, especially in the realm of medical technology.
- stcredzero 17y agoI have a couple of friends who worked for NASA, and I've met and spoken with others who worked there. The part of NASA associated with the shuttle is a bit ossified. One of my friends ported the software that tracks the shuttle's trajectory, and determines abort trajectories. He did that either right at the beginning of this century or the very end of the last. In any case, it was very recent, yet the use of version control software was considered a radical and risky move on the part of his group!
- dandrews 17y agoSo what specific problem in NASA's development methodology do you think would be fixed by your favorite VCS? From the few references I've bothered to google the existing development process is heavily regimented - if expensive - and their record is pretty good.
- stcredzero 17y agoThey also have a record of ignoring warnings of problems by engineers, and in the parts that launch the shuttle, ineffective motivation to achieve economies of scale. As in a lot of government projects, there's an incentive to bill expensively for things regarded as esoteric, hence a desire to keep things esoteric. My friend also told me about one control, which was something like a 10-key keypad, a commit button, and a nixie readout. It dated from Apollo. You'd send commands by dialing in alphanumeric codes. What was it like when they "updated" it to run on workstations? It was a 10-key keypad with a few other buttons, with an alphanumeric entry field. I don't necessarily want VCs running NASA. But it's for sure that there's some ossification in that government organization. Maybe it's time for private enterprise to step in?