8 ms·
Technology has created more jobs than it has destroyed, says 140 years of data
- minthd 11y agoLooking at current uk employment numbers[1] , it seems that healthcare , education accommodation and food services count as 23% of the economy. But : 1. Will they grow under new conditions ? These sectors historically didn't enjoy more productivity due to technology. Economists called this "baumol's disease". But this is changing. We're seeing higher education and maybe some lower education being automated. In japan we saw a robotic hotel, there's plenty of efforts to automate the food industry(both making and serving food), and in healthcare we're on the way to become much more effective at a fast rate with many(hundreds of genetic treatments in clinical trials,great improvements in targeted cancer therapies, artificial pancreases and continuous glucose monitoring are on the way to solve diabetes , etc ,etc) . 2. How much more can they grow ? Will said growth be enough to stop job decline in other sectors ? All those sectors grew due to stuff like cheap credit, degree inflation, more expandable income, growing country budgets, etc. But will those conditions continue to be true in a world with a lot of unemployment in other sectors - much more than we saw in the past ? Also - all those three sectors are 23% of the economy. We're talking about 40% of jobs at risk due to automation in 20 years. So those sectors would have to double/triple themselves to compensate. Is this realistic ? [1]http://www.ons.gov.uk/ons/rel/bus-register/business-register-employment-survey/2013-provisional/rft-table-1.xls http://www.ons.gov.uk/ons/rel/bus-register/business-register...
- toyg 11y ago> 1. Will they grow under new conditions ? Some conditions don't change. An OAP with limited mobility will always require assistance day-to-day, and it's the sort of thing robots are really bad at. OAPs are also growing in number, as life expectation increases. Another one: you will always need someone to help give birth - in fact, as hospitals are deemed too expensive and scaled back, we will likely need more nurses, since home-births stop them from sharing their time between patients. Again, this will not be touched by automation. I'm sure there are plenty of other examples. >2. How much more can they grow ? I think that's more a function of our social organisation than technology. The real question is basically "how can we pay these people?" -- morality and common sense tell us that a lot of these activities should not be linked to profit, but that is economically challenging unless we rethink how money is created and distributed. > We're talking about 40% of jobs at risk due to automation in 20 years. I find that number too high to be true. 10 or 20%, maybe; 40%, it's really hard to believe - that's 15 million people in the UK without a job, where currently we have 2.3million unemployed. It would mean basically 1 million newly unemployed people each year; I would argue society would not survive 5 years in such conditions, let alone 20. In any case, I have no doubt we can create more office-based bullshit roles to offset the bulk of those losses (dedicated entertainment people in every office; corporate psychologists; continuous-change oversight; dedicated corporate tailors; and so on and so forth...).
- minthd 11y ago>> I find that number too high to be true. 10 or 20%, maybe; 40% The 40% came from a study at oxford, which i think was a bit conservative , because it didn't take into account the possibility of creative jobs being automated. >> I have no doubt we can create more office-based bullshit roles Sure we can. But will we ? i'm not so sure. >> but that is economically challenging unless we rethink how money is created and distributed. If that happens , a lot of things would change, for both directions - more jobs and less jobs. >> Again, this will not be touched by automation. Automation is the less powerful technology working on healthcare. But if you can detect diseases very early , and have very effective , side-effect free and long-term treatments , healthcare will become more efficient. Or let's talk about limited mobility(your example) - a leading cause is severe arthritis. But maybe we can cure that ? >> home-births Maybe we'll see growth there.But i would guess it's not that big of job provider. and even for home births, there's telemedicine and remote continuous monitoring , i think in use today - saving work.
- pixl97 11y ago>I have no doubt we can create more office-based bullshit roles to offset the bulk of those losses In the U.S. we are creating software to get rid of those tasks. Yes, we'll hire a few programmers to make the software, and then cut 20 or 30 people out of an office. They don't get hired back. The company puts that money in the pocket of the owners. Every year the hardware and software gets cheaper to produce too.
- kristjankalm 11y agocan anyone find the link to the original paper? it seems to be by Deloitte but I have found nothing on their website nor just googling authors' names.
- AndyMcConachie 11y agoBeware the intoxicating belief in technological determinism ;)
- dotcoma 11y agoIf true, is this good? Isn't the purpose of work to end (or to diminish, at least) all work? (and leave us with more time to take care of ourselves, our minds, our bodies, our souls, our kids, our parents, our friends, our neighbours, our politics, our environment etc)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- martin-adams 11y agoI think this is good. Most species need to dedicate their effort to hunting/gathering/nest building, and having need to do work I think makes you appreciate and value the non-work time more. Technology has given me such an awesome way to make a living that makes me feel so lucky. Life for me now is far more enjoyable and easier than my time at school or college, purely because I get to work on the things I enjoy.
- nicktelford 11y agoIf this was the only effect of technology, it would obviously not be good. However, technology has also greatly improved the quality of life. I'd also argue that an end to work is something that we, as a society, are simply not ready for. Firstly, because our current economic system isn't capable of handling such a change, but also societally, people aren't ready for it. If I recall, there have been studies that have linked earlier retirement to a reduced life expectancy.
- binarymax 11y ago> there have been studies that have linked earlier retirement to a reduced life expectancy If you count retirement as sitting around doing nothing then I agree. But retirement shouldnt mean retirement from doing things - just retirement from working for someone else to be able to support yourself. When I 'retire' I'll get much more personally meaningful things done, which otherwise would not earn me enough money to support a family.
- 11y ago
- noja 11y agoPast performance does not guarantee future results. It's just an indicator.
- dunkelheit 11y agoI am more interested in another question: has technology created more leisure than it has destroyed?
- mavdi 11y agoI guess it that depends from person to person but I'd be definitely interested to see the general population happiness (not sure how they measure that) with tech. I personally can't stand tech anymore, it's what I'm forced to do to make a living. I'd rather stare at a tree than a mobile screen.
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoI think it's a good idea not to be too Western. Median living standards in the West have improved a lot over the last century, especially since WWII. But a lot of that improvement has been off the back of Rest of World, where slave-like conditions still endure. It's fine to have hairdressers here, but it's useful to remember that hairdressing is only possible because there are textile makers, miners, and farmers working in extremely harsh conditions elsewhere in the world. And there's also been incredible damage to the planetary carrying capacity, with effects that will become more and more obvious as the century progresses. So it's just as possible to argue that technology is more like a drug that works on generational time scales: you get a hit, you feel awesome for a while, then you fall apart.
- mavdi 11y agoAgreed. It well may be that technology temporarily enhances our lives while in the long run it's detrimental for our species.
- prodmerc 11y agoUh, yeah, because there was room to grow or move in to. In 1900 people were still settling in America, and production has grown immensely worldwide at a steady rate since then, while population was relatively low. Now, population has grown three fold in the last hundred years: http://www.historyfuturenow.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/populationgrowthhistory2.jpg http://www.historyfuturenow.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2012/1... There are more old people alive than ever before as a percentage of the overall population (I guess there's jobs in caring for them, unless robots do that, as well), and technology is at a point where it can replace humans completely, instead of working side by side. I always say, the Industrial Revolution = humans aided by machines (say a ratio of 1-100), the Automation Revolution = machines aided by humans (take the same ratio in reverse). You see the problem? Population is exploding, job automation is doing the same. In a society that needs to work in order to live, that is unsustainable. I'm all for automation, but we need something for those who will simply have nothing to do in order to make money... The people who own and maintain the machines will be fine, those who mediate relations between humans-humans-machines, as well. What about the rest?
- blumkvist 11y agoThere are plenty of jobs that cannot and will never be able to be automated. Like a kindergarten teacher. Coincidentally (or not so much) those are the jobs that improve society and life the most.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoWe will never need that many kindergarten teachers. Ultimately we'll face near 100% unemployment, or as they called it in the 1950, utopia. Why do we resist?
- prodmerc 11y agoYou can have only so many teachers before the market is oversaturated. And I think quite a few people will prefer home schooling via online courses.
- 11y ago
- jbb555 11y agoThis is self evident. Secondly nobody can argue that there are less things in the world that we want to do than there were 100 years ago. They are not the same jobs but can anyone really argue that nope, there is nothing left to do. Of course not, that's absurd. Technology has simply changed and expanded the areas to work in.
- ck2 11y agoI'm curious if in the 21st century those jobs are created in the same country they are servicing. Because India (customer service centers) and China (apple product assembly) would say otherwise. Technology has simply allowed easier outsourcing while funneling the profits to fewer and fewer people.
- aaron695 11y agoPointless article. We know this, I don't think anyone has ever said otherwise. We also have had positive growth and increased consumption over this time as well. When it will stop is the only interesting point now since there seems to be many indicators we are hitting limits.
- bryans 11y agoI think this article completely misses the point. The technological revolution happening right now is unlike any other in history, and is escalating faster than anyone realizes. We are really just entering the ascent of the S-curve, and things are already starting to advance dramatically on a yearly basis. Comparing the effects of technology between today and even 40 years ago (much less a century ago) is the epitome of apples-to-oranges. It is a meaningless comparison for all sorts of reasons. We're in a new and exponentially developing Renaissance, the likes of which we have no historical analogy for (not even the actual Renaissance or Industrial Revolution). It's incredibly exciting, but we're in for quite a ride over the next few decades, and our sociopolitical foundations are not prepared for it in the slightest. I think encouraging further procrastination of preparedness does a disservice to us all.
- pixl97 11y agoA rabbit in Australia, circa 1788. The biggest issue with our era of technological growth, is we really have no idea if it is sustainable socially or ecologically over periods of time. If we take human social structures out of current growth and look at the 'people like to work and create to survive issue as an individual' we can easily destroy the world around us. This occurs all the time in biological systems. The great oxygen catastrophe is a prime example. Each individual bacteria produced oxygen in order to survive. This worked fine for around a billion years. The bacteria had no means to realized that free iron and other rocks in the crust would absorb their byproduct only for so long. Once the saturation point was reached free oxygen filled the atmosphere and essentially poisoned the Earth for a time. The question is, 'is there a technological saturation point'? How quickly will technology continue to grow even if it is poisoning the social structures it was built on? Will people and society adapt quickly enough?
- gutnor 11y agoNot quite sure the article is making any point about technology that was not widely accepted before. Industrialization with its the social progresses, and the golden age post-WW2 are always taken as counterpoint in any discussion about impact of technology today, as is the article conclusion "where one avenue closes in the jobs market, others open.". The actual problem that worries people nowadays is if there is a limit to the number of avenues and if we are close to hitting it ? And even if new avenues open, how easy it is to switch to them physically ( they open in another country ) or practically ( they require high qualification level ) The article does not make a case for that at all. Increase in caring professions, for example, is government policy driven. Is the article claiming that technology what the key factor that drove those policies and that further automation will drive the state to push for even more caring professionals ? Anyway, I guess the only goal of the article is to give hope to Joe Reader. That is not a bad thing, after all, at the very worst, we are still only at the peak of employment and wealth and (without the singularity) the world will not brutally crash, it will slowly degrade leaving plenty of opportunities for everyone to get a clue. For others though, they would have guessed that with a population doubling during the same period and low current unemployment rate, it is obvious that some jobs must have been created somewhere.
- blumkvist 11y agoThere's a very popular youtube video that argues this point and people often cite it. The problem with this line of thinking is that you assume there are some new job types that come into play and they replace old ones. While it is true that we have some entirely new job types (i.e. programmer) majority of the shift is to jobs which were already defined. Did we have architects and physicians before the industrialization? Of course we did. We just have more of them now, because we don't need so many people to harvest crops. Do we have kindergarten teachers, ecologists, social scientists now? Of course we do. We will just have more of them after the digitalization, because we won't need so many people to take your money at Wallmart or drive trucks or do legal discovery.
- tim333 11y ago>the world will not brutally crash, it will slowly degrade I think if you look at the stats it's been slowly upgrading rather than visa versa. I don't see much sign of the trend reversing globally. Pessimists tend to look at worker living standards in the US where they have been kind of static, ignoring the poorest 80% of the planet where they have been shooting up. China for example has been transformed over the last 30 years.
- Tycho 11y agoWould this be a fat tailed process though? In which case 140 years of data would not be enough to draw conclusions from the change in mean, in terms of a long term trend.
- tim333 11y agoI'm not sure the number of jobs is that related to the amount of work needing to be done. It's more people like doing something and so will tend to do so. Otherwise as the number of people employed in agriculture dropped from like 70% to 2% over a couple of centuries it would of led to 68% sitting about. But instead they invent new things to do - say interior design or computer game design. Whether the person designing interiors counts as having a job or a hobby is down to whether people exchange money for the service which they tend to do in a way that is not terribly effected by what technology is involved. It will be interesting to see how it plays out when robots get smart. My guess is people will still work on their novels, designing stuff, acting and the like.
- Mimu 11y agoIf the only change is robots doing the jobs instead of people, my guess is most people will be starving to death on the streets.
- tim333 11y agoYou could get around the starving thing by the government taxing or owning the robots assuming they don't go all Terminator 2 on us.
- pliny 11y ago>It's more people like doing something and so will tend to do so You're putting the cart before the horse (or I misunderstood you). People have less they are required to do and use time they would have spent tending to their farm to ensure their survival, to pursue novelty and comfort instead. But people aren't great at entertaining themselves, so a lot of people are employed in the business of entertaining others. Comfort is also something that doesn't come easily, so a lot of people are employed in the business of doing menial tasks (like cooking and cleaning) for others, or producing furniture or machines that enhance our comfort.
- asgard1024 11y ago> People have less they are required to do and use time they would have spent tending to their farm to ensure their survival, to pursue novelty and comfort instead. Are you sure? Maybe what they are actually pursuing is trying to convince other people that some new job is sorely needed in the "new economy"?
- adrianN 11y agoEven if you accept that the trend of more jobs being created by technology than are being destroyed will continue indefinitely, fretting over technology replacing you if you're taxi driver is very justified. Having to learn a completely new trade is not easy.
- scotchmi_st 11y agoThen again, no-one ever said that you could learn a trade at 20, and that trade would still be relevant when you're 40. If capitalism is something you agree with, then you must also accept the transitory nature of your work. Although personally I do agree we should try to make it easier for people in that position.
- redblacktree 11y agoGiven this, it's truly tragic when a young adult takes on a mammoth debt to learn a skill that is then made irrelevant.
- Nadya 11y agoIt's unfortunate future-planning. It's impossible to know what the future holds but there is some level of precedent to help decide. Although with no guarantees, a job that has been around for hundreds of years is a bit more likely to stick around than a new job field that was just created 2 months ago. I'd go in debt to become a carpenter before I went in debt learning a JS Framework, as an example.
- alwaysdoit 11y agoSociety as a whole benefits, but there are high individual costs. We ought to figure out a way to smooth out those costs for the individuals.
- collyw 11y agoI am not sure it always does. Do you view the NSA's snooping technology as a benefit to society? More high tech, well paid jobs have been created there. Likewise I feel that a great deal of the tech involved in finance is of questionable benefit to society as aw whole. Does High frequency trading actually benefit anyone other than the banks?
- kristofferR 11y agoHopefully the trend is shifting soon. Let's just hope that the way we distribute wealth changes simultaneously, otherwise a lot of people will suffer.
- danielbarla 11y agoI have no real doubt this is true, but what may be different in today's situation is that something akin to true "artificial general intelligence" is not completely unfeasible (or something close enough to it that there's no practical difference). This is quite different to previous technological revolutions, where it was primarily manual labour that was automated. We seem to have in general conceded that many of those types of tasks can be better done by machines (with the exception of our adaptable intelligence, but how long will that be unique to us?). Now, people who are displaced by technology can move on to other things, but what happens if there really is nothing we're better at than a computer, in say 100 years?
- no_gravity 11y agowhat happens if there really is nothing we're better at than a computer It's not that you have to compete with computers while being naked and without tools in outer space. The line between Humans and Computers will continue to blur. Right now, you carry a computer with you in your pocket. Tomorrow you will have it in your head. And it will aid your thinking without you having to type stuff into a keyboard and looking at a screen. If there is nothing left "we" are better at then computers, the last remaining "old" parts inside of us will be discarded and we will just be a computer like everybody else :)
- aruggirello 11y ago> Right now, you carry a computer with you in your pocket. Tomorrow you will have it in your head. And it will aid your thinking without you having to type stuff into a keyboard and looking at a screen. You're assuming people will want it in their heads. I'd rather be naked and without tools, than become part of The Borg. YMMV though.
- no_gravity 11y agoThat reminds me of the time when mobile phones were new and some people told me "You will never see me walking around with a mobile phone. When I'm alone, I want to be alone! And not being reachable and connected all the time.". They all have mobiles now.
- samer66 11y agoBut is it the same elsewhere?
- obrero 11y agoIf this is true (and I take these things with an enormous grain of salt), it is an unfortunate thing. Tools are created to get rid of jobs, yet they create yet more work? In a rational society, more jobs being destroyed would be something to be celebrated. It is a sign of a sick culture in which it would be seen as a bad thing.
- kristofferR 11y agoTotally agree. Many people seem to believe that having to give away the majority of our most valuable non-renewable resource in life, time, in order to actually enjoy the remainder of our time, is a fantastic system that can't be improved upon. Sure, having to work was (and still largely is) a necessity, but we should make it unneccessary as soon as technologically possible. We act like being forced to do something is a right/privilige instead of a burden.
- x5n1 11y agoWhat this is actually showing is that wages continued to increase and the discretionary income that people had went back in the economy and the people found things to do that they could charge money for. So yes as long as there is money, people will find things to offer other people. That has not much to do with technology but more with the circulation of money.
- Super_Jambo 11y agoA large and growing % of the economy works to create demand through marketing & advertising. It seems like the number of jobs is more driven by the number of potential employees than the natural demands of consumers. I also find it interesting they highlight the decrease in professional cloth washers something technology has allowed us to DIY. Next to an increase in professional hair cutters something we previously DIYed with little technology. If someone makes a good hair cutting robot what will we outsource next besides food cooking and drink serving?
- asgard1024 11y agoCreating jobs is easy - you can always add more people monitoring if other people are following the rules - add more security guards, inspectors and managers. AFAICT the article doesn't make this distinction, and it is difficult - we don't have a standard way to consider this problem. The question is if it's worth it, and if it wouldn't be more useful to just let people work less and have more free time (for example through basic income).
- jaawn 11y agoNot all technology has an equal ability to displace human workers. I'd argue that the most displacing technology is just now being developed. Sure, some technology has a neutral impact on the job market, but some!=all
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]