3 ms·
I think the main party to blame here is Microsoft. They're pushing this "one-size fits all" solution into everything - from embedded systems to super-computers.
by mtgx 11y ago
I think the main party to blame here is Microsoft. They're pushing this "one-size fits all" solution into everything - from embedded systems to super-computers. To them it doesn't matter if Windows is "over-engineered" for a voting machine - it's just another license sold.
If it were up to me no embedded system would ever use the same operating system that's on a billion PCs. That's just asking for trouble.
- pjc50 11y agoDefine "embedded system" here: a ban on kiosk PCs? Could you apply the same logic to Linux, which is on hundreds of millions of PCs and also embedded routers? Is the problem just proprietary software?
- mtgx 11y agoLinux is not an OS, it's a kernel. There are hundreds of different distros (the actual operating systems) with various degrees of security from being worse than Windows to having ultra-hardened kernels and user-spaces. So from this point of view, I think it's okay for "Linux" to be in multiple things at once, because it's really pretty far from a "single thing". The embedded versions of Windows seem to be more like 90% of the desktop version of Windows, and with the "unification" strategy of Windows 10 that's probably more true than ever. It's debatable whether a kiosk PC that handles purchases should run Windows or not. What's the worst that can happen there? The owner loses his records and possibly all of his money. It only affects him so he can choose whatever he likes. If he wants a less secure OS and he's fine with the risk, that's okay. A voting machine (which is duplicated across a city or state or country) that's not secure affects millions of people. Seems to me that it shouldn't be using "mainstream" solutions that are the target of thousands of hackers.