3 ms·
It's very much worth reading the comments on this one, in which a Virginia elections official who was involved with these machines repeatedly defends them in a
by mikeash 11y ago
It's very much worth reading the comments on this one, in which a Virginia elections official who was involved with these machines repeatedly defends them in a delightfully earnest but disturbingly clueless manner.
One of the points he's stuck on is that WiFi is short-range and unreliable from outside a building. Thus hacking these things from the parking lot would be impractical because you couldn't get access. Apparently the very concept of directional antennas is completely unfamiliar to this person.
Another strange point is that these defects weren't known when Virginia chose these machines. To him, that seems to mean "therefore it was a reasonable decision." To me, it raises the question: why didn't anyone look into their security as the choice was being made? Apparently the process by which Virginia chooses its voting machines, or at least the process it used at the time, involves no third-party security evaluation. What the hell?
- enraged_camel 11y ago>>Apparently the process by which Virginia chooses its voting machines, or at least the process it used at the time, involves no third-party security evaluation. What the hell? Government RFPs pretty much never have a third-party evaluation process. Those cost money, which is almost certainly not in the budget. Also, the vast majority of the time the government already has a preferred vendor, and the RFP is simply a legally-required formality.
- nmrm2 11y ago> Apparently the very concept of directional antennas is completely unfamiliar to this person. IMO that was not the disturbing part. I don't expect elections officials to know anything about RF. What's disturbing to me is that several experts explain in very plain terms why his assumptions are wrong, and he persists in his misunderstanding.
- mikeash 11y agoI certainly wouldn't expect advanced RF knowledge, but satellite dishes are a common sight in this country, so I would hope that passing familiarity with the basic concept of directional antennas (even if they don't know what to call them) would exist. Even barring that, I would at least expect an official to know the depths of their own ignorance. If you don't know anything about WiFi, fine, but then don't try to make arguments about it. And yes, persisting in making those arguments, not only being ignorant of the subject but after being corrected by people who know, is a special kind of ridiculous.
- 83457 11y agoThey should sit every government official down and make them watch Mr. Robot to scare the crap out of them on cybersecurity