6 ms·
I am homeless. I did not read the entire article because the author really does not know what happened yet assumes the worst about the police. First, as someon
by Mz 11y ago
I am homeless. I did not read the entire article because the author really does not know what happened yet assumes the worst about the police.
First, as someone who is both homeless and seriously handicapped, I feel the article is offensive and dehumanizing to people like me for its clear assumption that poverty and a handicap makes someone incapable of being a real threat. That is beyond insulting and in no way helps get people like me and our actual problems taken more seriously.
Second, although there is plenty of classicism in the world and this does negatively impact my life, I think I am far more aware if its impact in online forums than IRL. Some people IRL make my life unnecessarily harder with their unfounded conclusions about me. More people online seem to dismiss the possibility that I have a brain and something of value to contribute to the conversation and so on.
Third, it is not uncommon for local cops to be familiar with local homeless people. A high percentage of people on the street have either medical or mental health issues. Many of them are self medicating with drugs or alcohol. Society as a whole needs to come up with better solutions, but, while waiting for those solutions, cops still need to protect the public from sometimes irrational behaviour. If they know this guy and have a long history with him, sending him to a hospital may be the most humane, compassionate answer available.
I was woke up one night by a cop looking for another homeless person who was wanted for violent assault. When I was woke up, it was very aggressive because he was looking for a violent man and prepared for the worst. When he saw who I was, he said "Oh, it's you. I know who you are. You can put your hands down." He then went into social worker mode. I had not interacted directly with the police in that town before but I was recognized and known to be not a troublemaker.
The antidote to racism, sexism, classicism etc is to judge individuals as individuals and take things on a case by case basis. This article is very guilty of not doing that. It makes sweeping judgements of both the cops and the individual they sent to a hospital, without knowing enough about what happened to justify those conclusions.
There are a great many things wrong with how we deal with homelessness in this country and I know racism, classicism, sexism etc are very real and do serious harm to people. But I don't see this article helping in any way to solve that problem.
- Mithaldu 11y agoThank you for explaining very clearly what is wrong with the judgements passed in that article. The entire thing felt wrong in a way i could not articulate, but you managed to articulate it in an amazingly lucid manner. :)
- devindotcom 11y agoCertainly we do not have perfect information here. But while it's possible that three or four cops might be needed to take down someone irrational and strong, there's no indication this was the case with the man in the article (the author was there) and the numbers are way off — more than a dozen officers. I've worked with folks in situations perhaps similar to yours (I did social work myself) and as part of that I had to work with the police too, and found (like you say) a sort of ecosystem at work there. And knowing that I am more willing to excuse certain behaviors by those on either side. But did you watch the video? They were stomping on his prosthetic leg, crushing his head into the ground. They weren't trying to take him to the hospital, they were working to send him there. That said, the way homelessness and mental illness are handled in this country is generally speaking just plain bad. Social services are being cut all over the place and everyone wants to pretend that doesn't have consequences. Not to mention the treatment of vets, societal denial of mental illness, etc. Anyway. It's a nasty business and never pretty, but what we've seen here is inexcusable — and as others have pointed out, an everyday occurrence.
- Mz 11y agoBut did you watch the video? They were stomping on his prosthetic leg, crushing his head into the ground. They weren't trying to take him to the hospital, they were working to send him there I watched a portion of the video. That isn't what it looked like to me. It looked to me like they were trying to reduce the odds of him smacking his head on the sidewalk in his struggles. Furthermore, the article itself states that although there were up to 14 police officers, many of them were trying to shield the man from view. It assumes they were doing this for nefarious reasons of covering up police brutality while simultaneously conplaining that the man's butt became exposed and was on view. The author seems to not allow for the possibility that cops were trying to hide the man's half naked state from view, both to protect his privacy and protect passersby from something most people would find offensive. I have two special needs sons. As a parent, I am abundently familiar with how hard it can be to prevent someone from endangering themselves or others without looking like an abusive asshole in the process. But, then, my father and ex husband were both career army, so I have very little patience with the ignorance of many civilians who have never dealt with genuinely violent situations. There are times when please and thank you simply do not work and stronger methods are required.
- runamok 11y agoThank you for your comments. The fact that the author did no real research on what led up to this outrage did jump out at me. It probably still would not justify this level of force but at least there would be some context.