2 ms·
HN title: Soylent found to contain unsafe levels of lead and cadmium Actual title: Soylent Under Fire for Allegedly Failing to Provide Adequate Warnings on Its
by jjoonathan 11y ago
HN title: Soylent found to contain unsafe levels of lead and cadmium
Actual title: Soylent Under Fire for Allegedly Failing to Provide Adequate Warnings on Its Labels
Relevant context: California's warning threshold and the FDA's safety threshold are different. Very different, if TFA is to be believed on the point of California defining the warning threshold as "detectable amounts of harmful chemicals." Mass-spec machines are very good at detecting small amounts of things...
Was the title changed after the link was submitted or did the submitter / moderator turn a reasonable title into trashy clickbait?
EDIT: changed post to reflect the fact that the trashy clickbait was exclusively on HN's side of the link.
- jotux 11y agoThe meat of the article was this: >The non-profit organizations says that two separate tests conducted on Soylent 1.5 at an independent laboratory revealed "that one serving of Soylent 1.5 can expose a consumer to a concentration of lead that is 12 to 25 times above California's Safe Harbor level for reproductive health, and a concentration of cadmium that is at least 4 times greater than the Safe Harbor level for cadmium." The HN title actually seems more useful than the original title.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- fredkbloggs 11y agoIt's not, but it's close. For example, if you go to buy a brass valve for some plumbing work, you will see two things: 1. A label that states "LEAD FREE", possibly stamped into the metal surface of the valve body itself. 2. A Prop 65 warning to California residents that the valve contains chemicals known to the State of California to cause cancer and birth defects or other reproductive harm. We can only assume that this is because "lead-free" does not actually mean that the item contains absolutely zero atoms of lead; it has a specific technical definition (NSF 61G) that is intended to prevent or greatly limit the likelihood that lead will be leached out of the fitting into potable water. According to California, that's not good enough, so you get a helpful stamp telling you that your fitting is lead-free and also a warning from California about (one assumes) the fitting's lead content. Umm... so is the fitting suitable for potable water system use or not? Thanks, California! (Example, if you're feeling lazy: http://www.homedepot.com/p/Everbilt-1-2-in-Brass-C-x-C-Full-Port-Ball-Valve-107-453EB/205821852 http://www.homedepot.com/p/Everbilt-1-2-in-Brass-C-x-C-Full-...). Prop 65 is basically useless, in that it requires you to be informed that a product, building, room, etc. contains one of a few basic classes of harmful substances, but it doesn't require that you be told what those substances are or anything else about them (like whether they're in a form that can harm you, how to avoid them, etc). Even worse are the countless manufacturers who have seemingly taken to labeling every product with something like "Prop 65 warning to California residents: this product may contain chemicals known to the State of California to cause {cancer, birth defects or other reproductive harm}" (emphasis mine). If you want to know whether it actually does, what those chemicals are, or the concentrations or forms in which they are present, I hope you work in a materials testing lab. And, oh yeah... the "Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act" and Prop 65 are one and the same, in case you weren't aware (see http://oehha.ca.gov/prop65/law/P65law72003.html http://oehha.ca.gov/prop65/law/P65law72003.html). None of this means that Soylent doesn't contain heavy metals in dangerous concentrations. It does mean that we can't really rely on a Prop 65 label, or a violation of Prop 65's labeling requirements, to tell us whether it does. If you want to know that, you don't need California law books, you need a mass spectrometer and related lab equipment. Personally, I'll stick to eating things that I grew myself. They might have heavy metals in them, too, but at least I don't have to worry about whether some Chinese supplier snuck a little something extra into some random "food" manufacturer's supply chain and neglected to tell anyone about it. But your life, your choice. Just don't expect the label to give you any guidance.
- _delirium 11y agoSeems to be fairly common; another lawsuit by the same organization over cadmium and lead labeling: http://www.confectionerynews.com/Regulation-Safety/Lead-and-cadmium-metals-in-chocolate-Hershey-and-Mars-face-lawsuit/?-Feb-2015 http://www.confectionerynews.com/Regulation-Safety/Lead-and-... California can't actually ban products with levels that meet federal thresholds due to federal preemption in the field, but they can add labeling requirements, which they've done under Proposition 65, which requires products or facilities not meeting the CA thresholds to post a warning saying, > WARNING: This product contains chemicals known to the State of California to cause cancer and birth defects or other reproductive harm. If you've been to California, you've probably seen those all over the place, e.g. a previous office I worked in had such signs posted at all the entrances. Beyond posting the sign, there is no other requirement, e.g. reducing levels isn't mandatory. Also, the federal vs. CA levels are sometimes orders of magnitude different.