3 ms·
> That said, there's a bunch of hard data that supports many of the assertions in the New York Times article What is the hard data? I only read about half the
by jessriedel 11y ago
> That said, there's a bunch of hard data that supports many of the assertions in the New York Times article
What is the hard data? I only read about half the NYTimes piece, and skimmed the rest, so I very well might have missed it.
> it's not a particularly interesting data point that "Amazon works for me."
Tim described his observations about a large number of co-workers, not just his own situation, and found them roughly in line with industry norms. He acknowledged the limitations of his observations, unlike the Times piece which lavishly illustrated shocking anecdotes in order give the reader the impression some behaviors were widespread. For instance, a reader of the Times piece would be forgiven for thinking that crying at your desk is the norm at Amazon, but I have now heard four Amazon employees say they have never seen that, and one that gestured vaguely like they maybe had.
- idlewords 11y agoIf you're going to argue this, and especially if you are going to ask that other people provide "hard data", have the courtesy to read the entire article.
- jessriedel 11y agoThis is a silly requirement (and seems equivalent to unfortunate perception that asking for tl;dr summaries is always bad, when in academics they are called "abstracts" and are considered essential). If someone obliquely cites one part of a long reference, it's not unreasonable to ask them to specify which part. And as you can see from his reply, it would not have been useful to read the article.
- bcantrill 11y agoWhat I meant was: "The assertions made by the New York Times piece are corroborated elsewhere." That is, to those who know AWS, it wasn't a terribly surprising article (Tim's shock notwithstanding).
- jessriedel 11y agoFair enough.
- carc 11y agoEveryone I know who works in AWS (several engineers, either closely or as acquaintances) say their experience was nothing like what the article described. My evidence is anecdotal, but so is NYT's. I'm not saying who's right here, but I don't think you can say an assertion is considered corroborated because you can find anecdotes supporting it..