30 ms·
Yes, exactly. The essay is attempting to tie the moment of creation for a concept to some event in the real world. Certainly there is something physical going o
by skybrian 11y ago
Yes, exactly. The essay is attempting to tie the moment of creation for a concept to some event in the real world. Certainly there is something physical going on which we call a "discovery" or an "invention", but it gets fuzzier the more you look at it.
We can objectively say that 1492 was an important year of first contact and we should talk about what happened. But it wasn't "discovering the New World" from the Native Americans' point of view.
Both in science and math, publishing a paper can be an important event and it's a physical process. But the first math paper published may not correspond to the first time someone had an idea or made an observation. If we're going to talk about a concept as a thing that exists in time and space, we need to take into account that ideas may be created, shared, and forgotten many times.
Perhaps we can think of Platoism as a way to avoid getting bogged down in the history of an idea by declaring it irrelevant for our purposes.