3 ms·
Folk tunes are more complicated than they sound. Jigs, reels, etc are all classes of tune, with broadly similar features. But there are further sub-groupings ba
by TheOtherHobbes 11y ago
Folk tunes are more complicated than they sound. Jigs, reels, etc are all classes of tune, with broadly similar features. But there are further sub-groupings based on date of composition, composer, and even location.
So if you feed an ML system a generic mix of folk tunes without understanding how the subgroupings work, you'll get a messy blob of musical data out. It will sound sort-of interesting in a work-in-progress way, but you will always have to hand-edit it to get something acceptable. And even then it will probably be mediocre rather than memorably great. And if it sounds at all good, you'll likely find you've created a mashup machine, not a true composer.
Really, it's like training an ML on "ballads". You'll get a few features that are similar, but everything else will be too noisy to be anything other than a crude attempt.
So I think good musical imitation is probably a lost cause, because the rules are so complex and contingent, even for "simple" music, that there simply isn't enough consistency to do the job.
At the same time the differences from the template create recognisable styles, which have emotional and other associations. So the differences are significant in their own way - but even noisier as a recognition problem.