3 ms·
The whole south, southwest, and west 3/4 of the city are zoned to only allow low density residential, have poor access to transit, spend huge amounts of space o
by jacobolus 11y ago
The whole south, southwest, and west 3/4 of the city are zoned to only allow low density residential, have poor access to transit, spend huge amounts of space on roads and parking, and basically require car ownership.
If there were better mixed use zoning (think 3–6 story buildings and looser parking requirements) in those areas and others throughout the Bay Area, and better transit, the whole region could fit many more people and reduce the stress on overall housing supply. Plenty of folks who live in low density residential areas don’t necessarily want to drive everywhere or live a suburban lifestyle, but are stuck there by housing prices in more urban areas. There could even still be a large number of single-family houses once you get 3–4 blocks away from transit stops, and they would be cheaper than they are now, because there would be less demand on them.
The whole city (and the whole Bay Area) has absurdly priced housing, and even in the southern/western areas of the city ($1500+/month per bedroom), rents suck up a huge proportion of people’s income and middle-class folks are priced out. Young people who aren’t in the tech industry can only afford to live in the city if they cram several roommates into a tiny single-family house or flat and spend 50% of their income on rent, and many service workers in SF are commuting in from far outside the city. The middle-income people I know in SF are mostly still there through rent control, wouldn’t be able to afford it if they were just moving in, and are stuck in their current house/apartment unless they want to completely leave the city.
As someone who grew up in a suburb, my personal opinion is that suburbs may be friendly for “families” but they suck for people aged 9–25, 65+, anyone single, or anyone who can’t get around by car or doesn’t enjoy driving everywhere. Luckily the low density parts of San Francisco are still pretty navigable by bicycle, and have reasonable access to downtown, so they’re not as bad as many other suburbs.
- raldi 11y ago> The whole south, southwest, and west 3/4 of the city are zoned to only allow low density residential Correct, pretty much. Everything yellow in this map is zoned 40-X, a.k.a. buildings taller than 4 stories are not welcome: http://i.imgur.com/Tn7CSTX.jpg http://i.imgur.com/Tn7CSTX.jpg (You can make maps like this at http://propertymap.sfplanning.org/ http://propertymap.sfplanning.org/)
- dublinben 11y agoI don't know how SF can call itself a city and not allow greater than four story buildings for most of its area.
- pbreit 11y agoWell, for many, that's one of the core appeals of SF.
- jacobolus 11y agoI know almost nobody who thinks a “core appeal” of SF is the low density and poor access to transit of the neighborhoods south of I280 or west of Highway 1. All the people I know who live in the western half of the city complain bitterly and incessantly about car traffic and how crappy the bus and light rail are. The charming parts of SF are all the bustling little neighborhoods in the northeast quarter of the city, which have easy walking access to anything you might need. If the low-density areas of SF doubled in density (we’re talking some percentage of 4-story low-rise apartment buildings instead of exclusively single-family homes), along with a commensurate improvement in transit, almost everyone would be thrilled, and the city would be more charming, not less. Here’s a zoning map. http://www.sf-planning.org/modules/showdocument.aspx?documentid=9016 http://www.sf-planning.org/modules/showdocument.aspx?documen... All the parts that are zoned as one housing unit per lot, with no allowance for commercial uses (RH-1), along with similar zoning throughout the Bay Area, are the cause of our current housing crisis. The name for it is “suburban sprawl,” and it’s a crappy way to organize a society, antithetical to community and to human health. (Not to mention, they are hugely inefficient from a resource-use perspective, and are at a national and international scale causing the destruction of the planet.) It would be lovely if some portion of those were re-zoned to RC-3 or similar.
- fra 11y agoI don't think the 4 story limit is the problem. The vast majority of buildings in Paris are 4 to 5 stories, and they achieve much higher density.