3 ms·
I really appreciate the effort that went into the performance part of this work. There was a real effort to try and make it sound like a reasonable representati
by bane 11y ago
I really appreciate the effort that went into the performance part of this work. There was a real effort to try and make it sound like a reasonable representation of humans playing...a little off beat, out of sync at times. Instead of just hammering the notes out like I hear with lots of these systems, it makes it listenable...I've had the endless trad on for 15 minutes now in the background.
I also like how the basic structure of the musical forms has mostly carried through the model, that seems to be a good "sniff test" if the model is producing reasonable output, if the musical structure makes sense as well as the notes. It makes it feel like there was a little bit of planning.
Great work.
- coldtea 11y ago>I really appreciate the effort that went into the performance part of this work. There was a real effort to try and make it sound like a reasonable representation of humans playing...a little off beat, out of sync at times. That said, there's a certain ways that humans interact when they play together (even if they track their parts independently). Just being a little off beat randomnly doesn't capture that, and can sound fake just as being perfectly on beat. There are a few algorithms about how actual players interact, here's a relevant study: http://scitation.aip.org/content/aip/magazine/physicstoday/article/65/7/10.1063/PT.3.1650 http://scitation.aip.org/content/aip/magazine/physicstoday/a... There are several more for real-life like quantization/humanization.