5 ms·
There's an objective distinction between "past", "future", and "undefined". ("Present" is sort of more a human concept than a physics one.) Past is in your past
by jerf 11y ago
There's an objective distinction between "past", "future", and "undefined". ("Present" is sort of more a human concept than a physics one.) Past is in your past light cone, future is in your future light cone, and "undefined" is everything else.
- gdavisson 11y agoI prefer to categorize them as "absolute past", "absolute present", and "absolute elsewhere". This is because for any event in one of your light cones (past or future), there'll be a reference frame that places it at your location (i.e. the same spatial coordinates, just at a different time). But for events outside your light cones, no reference frame will have it at the same location; it's absolutely elsewhere. BTW, if you also want to talk about the present, you can only talk about it at a particular location. If you want, you can define 3 "thin" boundary regions: the surface of the future light cone (boundary between absolute future & absolute elsewhere), the surface of the past light cone (similar), and the "here & now" (the single point in spacetime where all 3 regions meet).
- DougMerritt 11y ago> "Present" is sort of more a human concept than a physics one. Please excuse my quibble, but more precisely it is a classical/Newtonian concept rather than a relativistic concept. "Human concept" might map to "folk physics" (the version of physics assumed by "the common man" humans from current hunter-gatherer societies and older societies etc.) There are illustrations from the middle ages and from ancient Greece, if I'm not mistaken, that show the flight of an arrow to be a straight line up to apex, and then linearly down to target (rather than a realistic parabola) -- and although I've always wondered if an actual bow expert thought that's how it worked (unlikely), but apparently the non-archer philosophers of the day apparently did. But I digress. You are clearly just pointing out the modern understanding.