8 ms·
> No need for politics, in this case mathematically dictated incentive structures will decide who wins. Whenever I see a statement like this I smile because th
by pron 11y ago
> No need for politics, in this case mathematically dictated incentive structures will decide who wins.
Whenever I see a statement like this I smile because that's what politics is[1]. If many people decide to do something based on their interests (rather than, say, being forced to leave their homes because of an erupting volcano) -- that's politics. Thing is, people who say they hate politics usually don't know what it is, and the result is that they just do politics badly. You can't not have politics in any social structure -- it is an inherent process in any kind of social interaction. Whenever one person tries to convince someone to do something, or to reach any sort of an agreement -- that's politics by definition. Whether the incentive are mathematical (though they never really are when it comes to humans) or not doesn't matter. Politics is the process by which a decision -- any decision -- is eventually taken by a group.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politics
- zekevermillion 11y agoI agree that politics operate in bitcoin. I disagree that politics will decide which network branch remains in use, at least not conventional politics of influencing people through polemic, logrolling, or subsidy. Politics in the sense of any attempt at influencing people aside from the literal design of your favored protocol implementation. You may be correct to say that incentive structures designed in software protocol is in fact politics itself, a new and effective form of politics. In that case I would agree with you. Perhaps my original comment would be more interesting if I had thought of bitcoin protocol proposals as a form of politics!