2 ms·
Consider having a penalty box for a certain period of time once a flag threshhold is reached - e.g. a few hours (where the offense is clearly marked that the us
by cwan 17y ago
Consider having a penalty box for a certain period of time once a flag threshhold is reached - e.g. a few hours (where the offense is clearly marked that the user alone can see with a link to TOS) to shame someone into being more civil. If it's decorum that you're trying to change, then I'd keep the flag simple - e.g. an "ad hominem" flag. Part of the attraction for me to HN is its elegance and simplicity in great and relevant stories percolating to the top in addition to the unique and remarkable community.
Once an individual has a given number of penalty boxes, a moderator considers whether to ban them. The danger of doing stuff like this is that subjects that interest this community inevitably also spill over into the political realm and as others have pointed out the use of up votes and downvotes are ambiguous and further, open to abuse.
If you want to publicly shame someone, then once a member is on probation after a certain number of penalties/flags, add a dot or something relatively benign in color to their name.
Edit - I'd add that if it were up to me, I'd try to control personal attacks above all else given the community is pretty good at calling people out on comments that add little to no value.