3 ms·
All of the recent research I've seen on this topic seems to be moving in the wrong direction. WiFi is a shared channel, if someone is using it, you can't use i
by jrockway 11y ago
All of the recent research I've seen on this topic seems to be moving in the wrong direction. WiFi is a shared channel, if someone is using it, you can't use it. Thus it makes sense to minimize the range as much as possible; if your walls are attenuating the signal, that's great, because it means your neighbors can't interfere with your network. 2.4GHz and 5GHz already have too high of signal penetration (I see tens of networks on 2.4GHz in my apartment in Brooklyn), going down to 900MHz or 700MHz just means that if anyone in your city is using the channel, you can't use it. Needless to say, this is not going to make your WiFi experience more enjoyable.
Everyone hates running cables to the various floors of their houses, so I understand why people want more range. But more range for you means more range for other people, which means more interference.
Much of this can be mitigated by using a multiplexing mechanism more intelligent than carrier-sense, like CDMA. But as far as I can tell, the industry is resisting this heavily. LTE-U sounds like the idea is to bring LTE signalling to the unlicensed bands, so you can replace your WiFi router with an LTE router and have better use of the channel capacity (and sharing with other LTE networks). But the industry appears to be uninterested in this use case, instead focusing on tapping the ISM bands for more cell phone capacity.
TLDR: stock up on Ethernet cables. Sigh.
- Gibbon1 11y agoI had that gut reaction as well when listen to a marketing guy talk about devices with 5-10 mile range at 900MHz. The 900MHz band is 30 MHz. Not much when you consider population densities of 5-20,000 people per square mile. Side: I'm not really a WiFi guy but I think WiFi is based on listen before talk would means things like latency are going to be not so good when you have a lot of nodes. Not surprising because WiFi is basically 'wireless Ethernet' and has it roots in file transfer applications. I think LTE Unlicensed, developed by telephony guys will probably be better at serving low/deterministic quality of service applications in high traffic areas. Also rather than disinterest it's a matter that of some companies are interested in the technology and others see it as a threat. However what I read is they are talking about LTE-U on the 5.8GHz band.
- jrockway 11y agoThat's exactly right, and you bring up another few good points. 1) 802.11ac is 80MHz. If you are just getting a few megahertz between TV stations (I couldn't find the exact number), you aren't going to get your 1Gbps transfer rates with the signalling that WiFi uses. (In fact, you rarely get them in lab conditions, but I digress.) 2) With WiFi's signalling, multiple transmissions stomping on top of each other simply make both transmissions fail. LTE uses different sets of "tones" so that transmissions stepping on each other are still recoverable. (This is like how all the GPS satellites transmit on the same frequency, but you can still hear 10 of them at once. Clever math.) Certainly, I'd like to see unlicensed city-level wireless Internet that behaves as well as carrier-run LTE networks. You may not get a gigabit but even slow Internet is better than nothing. If anyone is researching this I'd be glad to send some donations their way :)