4 ms·
I had more math from 8th-11th grades than most people with Bachelor's degrees. I had no math my senior year because there were only three of us qualified for th
by Mz 11y ago
I had more math from 8th-11th grades than most people with Bachelor's degrees. I had no math my senior year because there were only three of us qualified for the next level math course, so they made it a zero hour class. I have a serious medical condition that was not yet diagnosed. There was no way I was going to go to school an hour earlier and take an extra class when I already had more math than I needed by far to graduate high school. The result was that when I started college, I was given a placement test and they said I could repeat trig or I could take calculus. Having had no math the previous year, I ended up dropping out of calculus. Years later, I tested out of college algebra and ended up getting the highest grade in intro to stats, something above 100 after they curved the grade, while explaining it to all my classmates because I seem to have long had a knack for explaining math.
Which is a long way of saying that although I am nothing impressive for the HN crowd, I am no math dummy either. And I don't feel I understand the point being made. I say that to say this: If the desire is to explain something to people who aren't very serious math people to begin with, then it probably isn't succeeding.
It sounds to me like the desire is to explain something to "outsiders," which is the only reason I am commenting. Because I sure as hell have no fantasy that anyone cares whether or not I get it.
- ColinWright 11y ago> Which is a long way of saying > that ... I am no math dummy ... Actually, what it makes clear is that you never encountered any real pure math. You only ever encountered what gets done in school under the heading math. Not the same thing. In fact, very far from the same thing. > I don't feel I understand the > point being made. ... If the > desire is to explain something > to people ... then it probably > isn't succeeding. Here's the bit that contains the main point: The whole point of pure maths is that there are problems to solve, and you're working to solve them. On the way you might generate all sorts of stuff that has no real relevance to the real world at all. The interesting thing is that stuff from pure maths ends up being useful anyway, even when they were studied just because they were interesting at the time. The rest is examples, structure, and motivations to try to help support that point. Does that help? If not, then ask something more detailed. > Because I sure as hell have no > fantasy that anyone cares whether > or not I get it. Given that I wrote it and posted it here, why should I not care whether you get it or not. The whole reason for writing it is to help people "get it."
- Mz 11y agoLet me restate my point: If you are trying to help "laymen" get some point, it isn't very clearly written. Singling me out and talking down to me in public in no way improves your actual article. Note to self: Stop trying to help other people. It's a bad habit that only comes back to bite me.
- ColinWright 11y ago> Let me restate my point: If you are trying > to help "laymen" get some point, it isn't > very clearly written. That wasn't obvious to me from your first comment - thank you for the clarification. I will read it again with your comment in mind, and see what I can do to improve it. > Singling me out ... I didn't single you out - I have responded to every comment that seems to need a reply. There is one other that I replied to first, the others don't seem to need replies from me. Yours did. > ... and talking down to me in > public in no way improves your > actual article. If you think I've talked down to you then I apologise. I don't believe I have, but clearly our ideas about what constitutes the nuances behind the words are different. I tried to take you exactly at your word and reply in a factual manner. I regret that you see it otherwise. > Note to self: Stop trying to help > other people. It's a bad habit > that only comes back to bite me. I have your email from earlier in my queue to be answered, and I will get back to you.
- Mz 11y agoThank you.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- DougMerritt 11y ago> Singling me out and talking down to me in public in no way improves your actual article. I think I see why you took it that way, but I am quite sure that that is not how Colin meant it, because I have seen him bend over backwards to educate, over the last decade or two. He said: > what it makes clear is that you never encountered any real pure math. That sounds bad to you at first blush, ok...but the thing is that it is literally true, not an insult, and not just of you, but of almost everyone who is not an outright mathematician, because "math" is not what people think it is. As a very general truth, it includes you, without at all picking you out from the general population. To a mathematician, the college 101 courses like calculus and calculus-based statistics (and their prerequisites like arithmetic, algebra, geometry, trig) are not "math", they are more like the alphabet is to an English Literature major -- absolute necessary, but too low level to be directly about the subject at hand. "Math" is about reasoning, not about e.g. knowing formulae to use on a pocket calculator. Colin's blog post implies that people with a mathematical turn of mind will itch to know answers. And I take it to be aimed at people who can sympathize with that itch: to know/understand answers to abstract problems. I don't speak for Colin, but I myself welcome you or anyone who itches to know the answers, and I am unapologetic about defining outsiders as those who don't care. It's not about your coursework scores, it's about what one's interests include, really. Disclaimer: Colin is a real honest-to-god mathematician, I myself am merely a philomath.