5 ms·
This comment (along with many of this author's other comments) seems to take a form which strongly reminds me of the output of SCIgen[1] and I wonder if anyone
by newsdotyc-ta 11y ago
This comment (along with many of this author's other comments) seems to take a form which strongly reminds me of the output of SCIgen[1] and I wonder if anyone more versed in quantum cryptography or any related fields of mathematics can make more sense of it than I can.
I could, of course, be unfairly interpreting the unusually simple [2] grammatical structures as being computer generated rather than as an artifact of not being a native English speaker. If that is the case, I do apologize and hope that I have not caused any offence.
[1] http://pdos.csail.mit.edu/scigen/ http://pdos.csail.mit.edu/scigen/
[2] Simple structures relative to the complexity of the topic(s)
- williamjennings 11y ago>This comment (along with many of this author's other comments) seems to take a form which strongly reminds me of the output of SCIgen[1] Whilst a context-free grammar is used to generate sentences; the preferred output is typically the sequence of words with the lowest entropy. That has the effect of sounding extremely concise, idiomatically as: a man of few words. I veritably assure you that you are indeed in communication with a real, live human being who has written software for Natural Language Processing; so I attribute your confusion to that point, mostly. >and I wonder if anyone more versed in quantum cryptography or any related fields of mathematics can make more sense of it than I can. Here is where you are being offensive. If you become confused by words which you cannot fathom, then you need to admit your own ignorance and ask a question directly. Otherwise, as in this case, you are engaging in fallacious excommunication or at least rude duplicity! >I could, of course, be unfairly interpreting the unusually simple [2] grammatical structures as being computer generated rather than as an artifact of not being a native English speaker. Here is where you espouse two falsehoods: that my grammatical structures are in any way simple; or that native English speakers have any specific level of complexity in their language. It is easy to show how certain grammatical constructions are indicative of a person's native language; but those are usually grammatical errors such as: run-on sentences, misplaced plurals, or redundant hyphenation. There is no homogenous measure of complexity for the English spoken by people born in England, so that topical premise is entirely wrong. >If that is the case, I do apologize and hope that I have not caused any offence. If you feel the need to apologize in advance, then you have probably written something rude; and you should revise the message before sending it. Let my wall of text be a lesson to you!
- anonbanker 11y agoThe fact that this wall of text is being greyed is a striking anti-intelligence mindset, and I'm shocked to see it coming to HN, frankly. This man was accused of being a bot for speaking to Ms. Rowan at a level she could address, and the replies are being greyed for pointing out rudeness.
- Pyxl101 11y ago> Server load balancing is a dynamic process which may actually induces vulnerabilities to distributed denial of service attacks, whether or not the maintenance occurs regularly. Especially dangerous DDoS is statistically timed to gain root access by damaging the infrastructure. I understand the topics that the words are referring to. The sentences seem like garbage that almost makes sense, but in the end doesn't. Presumably phrases or sentence fragments written by real humans but strung together in a nonsense way. One giveaway here is the phrase "whether or not the maintenance occurs regularly". What maintenance? There is no "the maintenance" in this paragraph, and maintenance has no connection to the sentence or topic. It's clever though and sophisticated enough to make you doubt yourself for a moment. I think it's both human and machine working together. This comment is too on topic to be random: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10058574 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10058574 I'm almost enjoying it as a kind of puzzle. Pretty sure it's some kind of performance art or trolling, so I've flagged it. I'm inclined to follow Poe's Law on this one ("Any sufficiently advanced troll is indistinguishable from a genuine kook") Edit: The user's subsequent replies distinguish their contribution as mean-spirited trolling.
- plumeria 11y agoCould it be some sort of Turing test inspired trolling?
- williamjennings 11y agoAs of yet, you are the only user to have made a remotely intelligent response.
- williamjennings 11y ago>I understand the topics that the words are referring to. This is an incomplete sentence. The correct phrase would be: "I understand the topics to which the words are referring" >The sentences seem like garbage that almost makes sense, but in the end doesn't. This is a Freudian slip where you are actually talking about your own sentences. Since when does garbage make sense? I hazard a guess that you are heavily invested in recycling content! >Presumably phrases or sentence fragments written by real humans but strung together in a nonsense way. This is another sentence fragment which is solely a predicate, lacking a subject. There is only one language in the world where that is valid grammar; and it is also the only one in which: being able to do the work of several humans- is an insult rather than a compliment. A moronic RUSE uses derogatives subjectively and assumes everyone else must agree. >It's clever though and sophisticated enough to make you doubt yourself for a moment. If you could veritably speculate on what type of computation was ongoing, then you too could be clever and sophisticated. Instead, you are simply being a dull sophist. >I think it's both human and machine working together. Correct! I am indeed using a computer, and so are you. >This comment is too on topic to be random: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10058574 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10058574 I'm almost enjoying it as a kind of puzzle. If this is some kind of algorithmic puzzle, then I am technically a 'wizard'; and you can only progress by asking questions to inform your own ignorance. >Pretty sure it's some kind of performance art or trolling, so I've flagged it. Another grammatical error! If you cannot think of a question to ask, or a related topic to discuss, then you are most likely the troll (or performance artist). >I'd argue that it's indecipherably dense and not appropriate for HN. I can now argue that in fact that you are indecipherably dense and HN is not appropriate for VC funding.
- anonbanker 11y agoShame on you for calling this man a Bot. You have created much controversy, and his original reply was buried/discredited as a result. Ideas were not heard. Flagged post accordingly.
- williamjennings 11y agoI am concerned about how this type of misbehavior could be moderated in the future. Sometimes posting on internet forums reminds me too much of Blade Runner. Then, anonbanker chimed in and the scene started to feel more like this song: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GLtzqaygG0s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GLtzqaygG0s Your concerns are appreciated and inspiring.