4 ms·
Going to America: A Ponzi scheme that works
- ojbyrne 17y agoRandom fact - Canada and Australia both have higher foreign born proportions - http://www.statcan.gc.ca/daily-quotidien/071204/dq071204a-eng.htm http://www.statcan.gc.ca/daily-quotidien/071204/dq071204a-en.... The article seems to phrase things specifically to not mention them.
- randallsquared 17y agoNeither Canada nor Australia have as much population as Mexico City. The article author could be forgiven for overlooking them. Edit: actually, it appears that the official figure for the Mexico City metro is 21M; I'd thought it was over 30M. Still true for Australia, though. :)
- ojbyrne 17y agoIt still weakens the author's thesis, and the paragraph talking about the comparison to other major countries doesn't read like he overlooked them, more like he deliberately omitted them. EDIT: I actually read the whole article now, and he actually mentions Canada and Australia as threats to the US near the end.
- petercooper 17y agoJust to add some rationale.. this is probably the coolest Economist article I've read in the last few months. It highlights some of the greatest aspects of brand America and why opening the immigration floodgates would be no bad thing. I think encouraging a policy of significantly increasing US immigration to people unlikely to cause a drain on the public system should override more selective policies like the "startup visa," as further general immigration can only continue to help America's cause.
- gcb 17y agoIt´s time we adopt a "startup visa:" prefix on links here, as it´s becoming a category lately
- kingkongreveng_ 17y ago> opening the immigration floodgates would be no bad thing Easily another hundred million people would move here if they could. That would be disastrous.
- petercooper 17y agoWould it? It might be, but I'd be interested to see the rationale. There's plenty of empty housing stock across the country that needs filling (and house values that most Americans would love to float upwards again) and the more people who live in the country, the bigger market for products, and the bigger the economy (though not necessarily higher in per capita terms at first).
- kingkongreveng_ 17y agoSlums of Manilla, Bogota, Delhi, Rio relocated? You really don't get that we're not talking about a bunch of guys in khakis and polos showing up ready to pitch in at the office on Monday? Believe it or not, the well educated and accomplished are generally happy where they are. The Mexican middle class does not emigrate. Freshwater issues alone dictate a fall in the standard of living with further population increases. The US got away with rather open immigration during the Ellis island wave by having virtually no safety net or public assistance. Over half of Italians who tried to make it here went broke and went home. If you want to kill every form of social welfare, public school included, maybe we can consider highly liberalized immigration. But not before.
- petercooper 17y agoBelieve it or not, the well educated and accomplished are generally happy where they are. The Mexican middle class does not emigrate. Not all, but I bet a reasonable percentage would take the option. For example, the UK (hardly a poor country) alone had 400,000 emigrants in 2008 - I'd doubt that many were poor.
- jacobolus 17y agoThe best extended treatment, still, 170 years later, is Tocqueville’s Democracy in America.
- redcap 17y agoWhile I'm sure I can look that up on wikipedia and get some idea as to what that article is, can you give some examples as to why? The economist article did a good job of showing that an open and tolerant America is good at getting people to come to the US and eventually blend in. It was also very relevant to the America of today, and suggested that despite some of the bad sides of America that are often amplified in the foreign press, because people have to work they're more likely to blend in. From what I read on wikipedia the 170 text does a very good job of explaining the nature of democracy in the US, and makes a number of predictions that pan out regarding party politics, but in your view is it still relevant for the America of the 21st century? I guess the angle I'm tacking from is the cultural aspects of integration versus what imo appears to be a treatise just about democracy (albeit what appears to be a classic).
- astine 17y agoFrom what I read on wikipedia the 170 text does a very good job of explaining the nature of democracy in the US, and makes a number of predictions that pan out regarding party politics, but in your view is it still relevant for the America of the 21st century? It is. DiA provides a very good picture on the character of the early American republic. It's very interesting to see how that character has progressed to the present day.
- jacobolus 17y agoIt’s several hundred pages and packed with insight – my copy probably has five or ten thousand words of my marginal notes in it – so it’s a bit hard to summarize in this little box. Basically, it describes how the American society and political system arose, and how they function. It analyses all of these seeming contradictions between freedom and dogmatic moralizing, etc. I think it’s probably the best book I’ve read about how popular government operates, and how it differs from exclusive elite government. Also, many of the differences Tocqueville finds between European and American society are still relevant today. If you want to know how the conditions described in this Economist article arose, and how these various features interact – what the “character” of (even contemporary) America is – in a deep way, I can’t think of a better book.
- gcb 17y ago"[america ranking low in tolerance] is a mistake. Some religious countries are indeed intolerant, but America is not one of them" this seems to be a good ecnomist article, but its filled with propagada. america ranks below for tolerance not because of religious reasons, but because its a police state where the people have no means of contesting acts and policies of some obscure gov branchs. right now im on the verge of moving to there, but im scared as shit of the random people dispearing for ties with terrorism. Fair its still a small number, and they even might be terrorists, and more importantly its no one you know. But that there are cases, that are.
- jacobolus 17y ago> [this article is] filled with propagada. [sic] [... America is] a police state. Give me a break. People in America have all kinds of “means of contesting acts and policies.” There are problems with the justice system, as anywhere, but the courts and the political system are more accessible in America than anywhere I know.
- gcb 17y agoYou know very few places. but i agree that i got the most difficult, and extreme, example of the dozen i could have used.
- alanthonyc 17y agoAnd where are you from? As far as I know, America invented the modern incarnation of a country with "means of contesting acts and policies of...govt." The fact that America's faults are bandied about for all the world to discuss, dispute and analyze just goes to show how good of a government it is. It's like an open source version of government.
- btilly 17y agoI was born in the USA and currently work here. I am fully aware of what the Constitution says and how it has been subverted. For example consider the 4th amendment protecting us from unreasonable search and seizure. As http://www.aclu.org/national-security_technology-and-liberty/are-you-living-constitution-free-zone http://www.aclu.org/national-security_technology-and-liberty... points out, 2/3 of the country lives within areas where the border patrol both can and sometimes does periodically set up spots where they randomly stop and search whoever they want. In pursuit of the "war on drugs" courts have come to accept that if your belongings are directly sued that you personally have no standing to contest the lawsuit, and your protections against unreasonable seizure is null and void. Telecom companies at the request of the Bush government made virtually everything tappable with no oversight. This activity has continued, and telecom companies have by special act of Congress (the current President voted ye on this) been given immunity for their violation of our privacy. We are not an extreme police state. But we are well on our way. As a random example, in the last several years at every job I have worked at I was unable to enter or leave my place of employment without a security badge. Just 30 years ago this kind of widespread use of pervasive security systems was considered unthinkable in this country, and people were proud of it.
- kingkongreveng_ 17y agoWhen is the country full? The US is arguably overpopulated by 100 million. It is not possible to be an environmentalist and favor continued high immigration rates. All this talk about importing "talent" is highly disingenuous. The bulk of current immigration is low skill and puts pressure on low-end wages, and many government services budgets. The history of immigration in America is a handful of waves interspersed by much longer periods of assimilation with close to zero immigration. The current wave, beginning in 1968, is absolutely unprecedented in volume and length.
- philwelch 17y ago"It is not possible to be an environmentalist and favor continued high immigration rates." Why not? People strain the environment wherever they are--increased population density and urbanization can often reduce that per-capita strain.
- petercooper 17y agoHow is the US "full?" Its population density is through the floor compared to almost every EU country and Japan. Further, it has a significant amount of natural resources and spare capacity right now. By your yardstick, the UK should be considered to be positive heaving, yet immigrants currently make up a majority of the population increase. I'm not going to complain - it keeps my house value up :-)
- kingkongreveng_ 17y ago> it keeps my house value up On a regular working man's salary my grandfather could rent a house on a pristine, practically undeveloped beach for a month a summer a short drive from a major east coast city. You are arguing it's a good thing that population growth has made this no longer possible.
- randallsquared 17y agoYou still can for most east coast cities. Probably less so in the northeast, though even there, southeastern Delaware is only about five hours from NYC, which is fine if you're going for a month, or every weekend for a month. A bigger issue for that scenario would be that most people don't get a whole month off in the summer.
- mcantelon 17y agoIf I were to migrate somewhere, I'd migrate to an emerging country rather than one currently being looted by massive funneling of currency towards finance industry insiders, HMOs, and defense contractors. The Economist can act as cheerleader all it wants, but the US debt has risen to dangerous levels.
- ggrot 17y agoGreat article, stupid title. They don't explain why immigration is a ponzi scheme "that works".